2019 年 42 巻 3 号 p. 496-500
Morinda citrifolia L., known as noni, originated from Indonesia exhibits various pharmacological activities including anti-inflammatory properties. However, the validity of noni fruit juice as a treatment for rheumatoid arthritis (RA), an autoimmune disorder, has not been confirmed yet. Therefore, the main purpose of this research was to evaluate the efficacy of noni fruit juice (INFJ) made in Indonesia using SKG mice as an animal model of RA, which shows the resembling characteristics of human RA patients. Furthermore, the safety of INFJ was examined by repeated dose experiments in mice. INFJ was mixed with water at 50% and administered to SKG mice sensitized with mannan, free access for 4 weeks. Arthritis scores of fore- and hind-leg joints were measured and the joints were histopathologically examined. The sub-acute and sub-chronic toxicities of INFJ were evaluated using BALB/c mice. The arthritic scores were significantly lower from the 7 d after sensitization in the INFJ group than the control group. Histopathological examinations of the joints revealed inhibition of severity of RA. In both toxicity studies, INFJ did not show any toxicities. INFJ exhibited anti-arthritic activity in arthritic and histopathological examinations of the joints in SKG mice. Present study was the first report where noni juice may be effective against RA. The dose of noni juice showing efficacy against RA was confirmed safe from repeated dose studies in mice.
Rheumatoid arthritis (RA) is a chronic autoimmune disorder that primarily affects the synovial membranes of multiple joints, resulting in damage to cartilage and bone around the joints.1–3) Though RA occurs in 0.5–1.0% of the adult population worldwide and is common in females than males, ethnicity, residence or climate are not important factors in prevalence of RA.2,4) RA is initiated by autoimmune CD4+T cells because of the presence of autoantibodies, such as rheumatoid factors (RFs), and is related with particular haplotypes of the HLA-DR gene.4)
During the past few decades, many kinds of medicines such as disease-modifying antirheumatic drugs, biological agents, steroidal drugs, and non-steroidal anti-inflammatory drugs have been developed for RA. Unfortunately, there is still no effective medicinal treatment that has the ability to completely cure this disease. Moreover, some adverse effects such as infections and declined immune functions are reportedly caused by the long-term use of the drugs. Therefore, it was underway that researches to develop new synthetic medicines and assessment of the applicability of herbal natural medicines to the treatment of RA.5)
Morinda citrifolia L. (Rubiaceae), commonly known as noni is Indonesia-origin tropical herbal plant.6) Noni has a long history of use as a herbal remedy for various diseases in Indonesia where noni is commonly called as mengkudu or pace, and individual houses in rural regions grow at least one noni tree at their garden to prevent or cure diseases. From our knowledge, noni has been utilized as nutritional and medicinal fruit since the present Indonesian people were immigrated to Indonesia 6000 years ago and thereafter it was spread to Micronesian and Polynesian areas with boat immigration people because of its benefits for health and disease treatment. Noni fruit is one of the most important traditional medicinal products called Jamu in Indonesia. In Indonesia, noni juice products are classified as semi-ethical medicine. Since noni fruit was reported its anti-cancerous action,7–9) noni fruit has been popular and resumed as natural functional healthy food in the world. Anecdotal evidences demonstrate the biological activities of noni, including its potential anti-microbial, anti-cancer, anti-oxidant, anti-inflammatory, analgesic, hypotensive, anti-diabetic, and cardiovascular activities.7–10)
The RA model of an animal is classified roughly into two models that develops arthritis by sensitizing collagen or Freund’s adjuvant, and a model that occurs naturally. Arthritis of Complete Freund’s Adjuvant (CFA) model was induced by injecting CFA-which is effective in stimulating cell-mediated immunity and leads to potentiation of T helper cells and also to the production of certain immunoglobulins and effector T cells. CFA model resembles arthritic in human by mimic clinical and pathological features of human RA such as swelling, bone erosion, cartilage degradation and loss of joint functions.
On the other hands, the SKG mouse is a BALB/c mouse that has a mutation on the gene encoding the Src homology 2 (SH2) domain of the zeta-associated protein of 70 kD (ZAP-70), a key signal transduction molecule in T cells. This model spontaneously develops chronic autoimmune arthritis under conventional microbial conditions or following an injection of β-glucan-containing products (such as mannan) under specific-pathogen-free (SPF) conditions. Arthritis in SKG mice is characterized by symmetric affections in the small joints, elevations in interleukin (IL)-1, IL-6, tumor necrosis factor (TNF)-α, and rheumatoid factor levels, joint destruction, and reduced bone density in addition to systemic manifestations including inflammation in the skin, blood vessels, and lungs, which resemble the clinical and histological characteristics of human RA.11–16)
Thus, both arthritis models cause similar joint changes. However, in order to develop potency of natural functional foods with new therapeutic substances and clarify their modes of action against human RA, autoimmune SKG mice model mimicked human chronic autoimmune arthritis is suitable rather than CFA model. This selection is based on the fact that SKG mice model as well as human RA spontaneously develop chronic autoimmune arthritis symptoms dominantly affected by genetic abnormalities.
In present study, we evaluated the antirheumatic effect of Indonesia-origin noni fruit juice (INFJ) using RA model animals, SKG mice. In addition, safety of INFJ was evaluated in sub-acute and sub-chronic toxicity studies using BALB/c mice.
SKG female mice (16-week-old) were purchased (CLEA, Japan) and used as an animal model of RA. BALB/c female mice (16-week-old) (SLC, Japan) were used for the toxicity tests. Both experimental animals were housed 3–6 mice per cage under 12-h light/dark cycle conditions (lights on and off at 7:00 and 19:00, respectively) at room temperature (24 ± 1°C) and humidity 60 ± 10%. Experiments were performed after formal approval by the Institutional Ethical Committee for Research on Animals, Toyama University.
INFJ used in all studies was provided by M&K Laboratories Inc. (Matsumoto, Japan). INFJ was made from ripe noni fruits, freshly squeezed without the addition of water or preservatives, and produced under Hazard Analysis and Critical Control Pointsystem in Indonesia. In the present studies, INFJ was mixed with drinking water at concentration of 50% (v/v).
SKG mice were divided into two groups. One group was given free access to 50% INFJ for 4 weeks, and the control group was given free access to water only. The administration of INFJ began from 1 d before immunization. Mannan (Sigma-Aldrich, U.S.A.) was suspended in phosphate buffered saline (PBS) (+) solution and injected intraperitoneally at a dose of 20 mg to induce arthritis. Body weights and fluid intake of both groups were monitored 3 times weekly. Body weights were measured every day, and the fluid intakes were calculated as total intake per cage (n = 6) per a day.
The arthritic score of each mouse was evaluated by the sum of total score of wrist and ankle joints by referring to the arthritic scoring system developed by Sakuguchi et al.11) Arthritis was graded on a scale of 0–1.0 for each wrist/ankle: 0 = no joint swelling; 0.1 = swelling of one finger joint; 0.5 = mild swelling of the wrist or ankle joint; 1.0 = severe swelling of the wrist or ankle joint.
On day 28, SKG mice were sacrificed and the right and left wrist and ankle joints from 6 animals in each group were collected and fixed with 10% neutral fomalin for histopathological evaluation. Each joint was longitudinally cut and decalcified. After routine dehydration, the specimens were embedded in paraffin, cut into 5-µm-thick several sections, and stained with hematoxylin-eosin. Total 48 slides from all the wrist and ankle joints were examined under a light microscopy in a blind method.
Severity of the lesions in each joint was scored on 0–3 grades based on the histopathologically characteristic changes of RA and with reference to commonly used histological grading as follows.17) Synoviocyte proliferation was graded on a scale of 0 to 3: 0 = one cell layer; 1 = 2–3 cell layers; 2 = 4–5 cell layers; 3 = more than 6 cell layers. Inflammation was graded on a scale of 0 to 3: 0 = no inflammation; 1 = slight inflammation; 2 = moderate inflammation; 3 = severe inflammation. Pannus formation was graded on a scale of 0 to 3: 0 = no formation; 1 = localized pannus formation without the destruction of cartilage or bone; 2 = definite pannus formation with the partial destruction of cartilage and bone; 3 = wide range in pannus formation and the destruction of cartilage and bone.
The histopathology of each mouse was evaluated by the sum of all scores in the wrist and ankle joints.
BALB/c mice were divided into two groups, and were studied for 28 and 90 d. One group was given free access to 50% INFJ, while the control group was served with water. After the end of each period of administration, blood samples were taken and then hematology was measured (Sysmex F-520, Japan). Serum were obtained to measure liver (Alanine transaminase (ALT), Transaminase CII Reagent Kit, Wako, Japan) and renal functions (Blood urea nitrogen (BUN), BUN Reagent Kit, Arbor Assays, U.S.A.).
Data were recorded as the mean ± standard deviation (S.D.). Groups were compared by one-way ANOVA and differences between groups were analyzed using Student t-test. A probability level of less than 0.05% was evaluated to be significant.
Fluid intake was lower in the INFJ group than in the control group throughout this study (Fig. 1, left). The lowest intake of INFJ was observed on day 2 after the mannan sensitization. On day 2, fluid intake per cage in one day was 14.6 g in the control group and 8.7 g in the INFJ group. Fluid intake was 40.4% lower in the INFJ group than in the control group on day 2. However, the decrease in fluid intake observed in the INFJ group did not lead to significant differences in body weights (Fig. 1, right).
SKG mice were given 50% (v/v) INFJ (closed diamond) and the control group received drinking water (open circle). Each value of fluid intake represented fluid intake per cage in 1 d (each group contained 4 mice per cage), while each value of changes in body weight was the mean ± S.D. (n = 4).
Significance differences were observed in arthritic scores between the two groups from days 7 to 28 after the mannan sensitization (p < 0.05 or p < 0.01, Fig. 2). On day 28, arthritic scores were 2.24 ± 1.53 (mean ± S.D.) in the control group and 1.11 ± 1.10 in the INFJ group. The arthritic score was 50.4% lower in the INFJ group than in the control group, indicating INFJ prevented progression of RA.
SKG mice were given 50% (v/v) INFJ (closed diamond) while the control group received drinking water (open circle). Each value was the mean ± S.D. (n = 15). *: p < 0.05 and **: p < 0.01 vs. the control group using the t-test. Arthritic scores were significantly lower in the INFJ group than the control group from day 7 after the Mannan sensitization.
In the control group, typical changes were observed in multi-layered proliferation of synoviocytes with mononuclear and neutrophils infitration, pannus formation and nutrophils-rich exudates in the joint cavity (Figs. 3, A, B), but not severely in the INFJ group (Figs. 3, C, D).
Marked changes in synoviocyte proliferation with inflammation and pannus formation were observed in the control group (original magnification, A and magnification 40×, B; respectively), but not in the INFJ group (original magnification, C and magnification 40×, D; respectively).
The histopathology scores were significantly smaller in the INFJ group than the control group, particularly for inflammatory cell infiltration and pannus formation, and the statistical analysis of total scores revealed significantly smaller scores in the INFJ group (Table 1, p < 0.05).
Each value was the mean ± S.D. (n = 6).
Parameters of safety of INFJ did not demonstrated any toxic findings in hematology and hepatic and renal functions, though BUN was higher in the INFJ group than the control group in 28-d administration study. However, BUN value was within normal range and no change was found in 90-d study (Tables 2, 3).
Each value was the mean ± S.D. (n = 6). not significant (N.S.).
Each value was the mean ± S.D. (n = 6–12). not significant (N.S.).
In order to evaluate anti-arthritic therepeutic effects of medicines, it has been common to use artificially induced arthritis such as type II collagen-induced arthritis. However, artificially induced arthritis is limited to examine the modes of naturally occurring arthritis in human because of non-physiological conditions. Recently, there are some animal models of RA developed naturally. One of them is SKG mice. SKG mice, a mutant of the gene encoding ZAP-70 on the BALB/c strain mice, spontaneously develop IL-17-secereting CD4 + T cells (Th17 cells)-mediated autoimmune arthritis clinically and immunologically resembling human RA,11) and arthritis is induced by activation of complements. C5a is the key complement to promote arthritogenic T cells and their Th17 cell differentiation in arthritic joints of mannan-treated SKG mice under SPF animal environment.16) In the present study, mannan was injected to evoke SKG arthritis. The arthritis shows joint swelling and characterized by subsynovial inflammatory cell infiltration, proliferation of synoviocytes, and pannus formation. They closely resemble the joint pathological findings of human RA.11)
Noni is one of Indonesia-origin tropical herbal plants and its fruit juice is prescribed as effective medicine for RA and several studies have confirmed the anti-inflammatory effects of INFJ.18–22) The effect of INFJ for RA was evaluated using CFA induced arthritis rat.23) However, there are no reports to evaluate the potential of noni fruit against RA resembling to human RA.
INFJ diluted to 50% was used. From preliminary studies, we decided to give INFJ by free access, but not gavage oral administration because the animals must not be exposed to stress by daily gavage dosing. Due to characteristic of INFJ with particle segments, 100% INFJ did not pass through a nozzle of water bottle. Finally we decided to apply at 50% INFJ which was the highest concentration for the mice to drink. In this study, we aimed to examine anti-arthritic potential using SKG autoimmune animal model. After 7 d from mannan treatment, the arthritis was developed at both the ankles and wrists and its severerity became prominent along with the experiment period of 28 d in the control group. INFJ inhibited significantly in arthritic scores compared with the control group. Histopathological examination demonstrated the typical arthritic changes with inflammation, proliferation of synoviocytes and pannus formation. In the control group, neutrophil-rich exudates in the joint cavity were found in some cases. INFJ administration significantly suppressed the characteristic lesions of RA compared with the control group, though the grade of inflammatory cell infiltration was not statistically significant. In statistical analysis of total scores, histopathological grade of lesions was significantly lower in the group served with INFJ than that with water. The arthritic scores of the joints were almostly comparable with histopathological evaluation in inhibition of severerity of SKG mice arthritis.
The mechanism of the anti-arthritic effect by noni juice is not fully understood. Now, we are studying the influence of compounds isolated and identified from INFJ on signal transducer and activator of transcription (STAT)3 and IL-6, which play important roles in inflammation pathways, including those in RA. Part of the compounds showed the suppression effect of STAT3 expression and IL-6 production in vitro. Therefore, we consider that some compounds contained in noni juice may indicate anti-RA effect. Currently, detailed mechanisms regarding noni extract compounds are evaluated in vitro and in vivo.
Noni fruit juice was served free access to SKG mice. Water intake was smaller in the INFJ group than the control group. This might be associated with poor palatability to INFJ that gives unique taste and odor associated with medium chain fatty acid-esters.8,9) However, there was no significant change in body weight in both groups. This indicates that lower intake of INFJ may not affect in anti-arthritic actions.
There are a few cases of hepatotoxicity associated with noni fruit juice in Caucasean societies.24–26) The INFJ which caused it was originated from French Polynesia and formulated with flavor and other fruit ingredients. Therefore, INFJ was exploratory evaluated its safety by 28 and 90 d repeated dose tests in BALB/c mice in the same administration way as the arthritic study. All the parameters measured did not reveal adverse events in hematology and hepatic and renal functions.
This is the first study that INFJ was demonstrated effective against RA in SKG autoimmune animal model resembling human RA. The results indicate that INFJ may lead to be safe and effective RA therapy.
The effects of INFJ for RA were evaluated using autoimmune RA model. It is concluded that the INFJ significantly inhibited both arthritic and histopathological scores and was found safe in repeated dose toxicity studies. The identification of active ingredients in INFJ and elucidation of the mode of action for anti-arthritis actions remain for further investigations.
This work was supported by JSPS Core-to-Core Program, B. Asia-Africa Science Platforms.
The authors declare no conflict of interest.