人間環境学研究
Online ISSN : 1883-7611
Print ISSN : 1348-5253
ISSN-L : 1348-5253
論文
障害基礎年金不支給決定取消等請求事件に関する判例研究
最高裁判所第三小法廷平成19年10月09日判決(平成18年(行ツ)第227号)判例集未登載
神山 智美
著者情報
ジャーナル フリー

2008 年 6 巻 1 号 p. 1_43-1_49

詳細
抄録

This essay is to interpret and to add some comments for the Legal Case of Repeal Request (Judgment of the Supreme Court on Oct. 09. 2007). On this case, Plaintiff, the students over 20years old, who go disabled persons, insisted that the National Pension Law was illegal and claimed that Disability Pension Incompetent Ruling for them should be repealed. First, the HIROSHIMA District Court judged the National Pension law was unconstitutional legislation and accepted a part of asserting plaintiffs' rights to receive state compensation (on Mar. 3rd. 2005). Later, the HIROSHIMA High Court rejected the former judgment and give decision that the National Pension Law was not necessarily unconstitutional legislation and state compensation does not needed (on Feb. 22. 2006). Finally the Supreme Court upheld the High Court judgment (on Oct. 09. 2007). I compared this Repeal Request judgment to other judgments and stated that the judge should be accepted a part of plaintiffs' claim because of the National Pension Law's unconstitutional.

著者関連情報
© 2008 人間環境学研究会
前の記事 次の記事
feedback
Top