組織学会大会論文集
Online ISSN : 2186-8530
ISSN-L : 2186-8530
パーフェクト、ホット、社会的レレバンス
-研究の品質と社会的評価-
尾田 基猪股 優史
著者情報
ジャーナル フリー

2020 年 9 巻 1 号 p. 203-208

詳細
抄録

The authors discuss what criterion should be applied to evaluate the quality of research papers. Some papers are praised for their rigorousness or accuracy, while others are praised for their creativity or originality. To make a meaningful discussion about the criterion to apply normatively, we develop two mathematical models to illustrate the methods researchers use to evaluate the qualities of papers. Perfect-model places more significance on rigorousness or accuracy of papers, while Hot-model places more emphasis on creativity or originality. Through examining these models, we hypothesize a relationship between the criterion researchers apply and the effects of academic contribution to socio-democratic impacts or the soundness of academic community and its development. Finally, the implications for both building a sound and intellectually, active, academic community and accumulating knowledge in the foremost caveat of valuable scholarly and social progress are introduced.

著者関連情報
© 2020 特定非営利活動法人 組織学会
前の記事
feedback
Top