One percent cefmenoxime (CMX) ototopical solution was administered to 302 patients with purulent otitis media and acute diffuse external otitis in open study fashion, and to 216 patients with purulent otitis media in double blind condition. From among the total of 518 cases various bacteria were detected, except 22 of negative detection after incubation and 3 of impossible determination. The main bacteria detected from the above 493 cases were
S. aureus (242 strains=49.1%),
P. aeruginosa (105 strains=21.3%),
S. epidermidis (67 strains=13.6%),
Proteus spp.(indole positive)(31 strains=6.3%) and
P. mirabilis (24 strains=4.9%) as well as anaerobic bacteria (26 strains=5.3%).
MIC of CMX against those bacteria detected was evaluated at 10
8CFU/ml and 10
8CFU/ml, respectively, up to the concentration of 800μg/ml, with MIC of cefazolin (CEZ), chloramphenicol (CP) and fradiomycin (FRM) as the references.
1. With respect to the antibacterial action of CMX against
S. aureus, MIC
50 of CMX was inferior to that of CEZ by 4-fold, but its MIC
80 and MIC
80 are almost equivalent to those of CEZ. These results were obtained because there existed relatively few CMX highly resistant strains, while more than 20% strains are said to resist cephem antibiotics.
2. As far as MIC of CMX against
P. aeruginosa was concerned, the MIC reached its peak with 100μg/ml at the concentration of 10
8CFU/ml and with 25μg/ml at 10
6CFU/ml, respectively, which indicated the real antibacterial value of CMX against
P. aeruginosa. However, the strains which showed higher MIC of >800μg/ml were rather few, that is, only 8 out of 105 (7.6%).
3. Antibacterial action of CMX against
Streptococcus (except
Enterococcus), GNR from intestinal bacteria and anaerobic bacteria was favorable, and the stable and strong antibacterial action was shown against
C. freundii, Enterobacter spp.,
S. marcescens and
Proteus spp.(indole positive) which produce chromosome mediated β-lactamase. On the other hand, the antibacterial action of CMX against GNF-GNR except
P. aeruginosa was unfavorable for
P. cepacia, P. putida and
A. xylosoxidans, but relatively favorable for
A. calcoaceticus.
4. As a result of MIC evaluation of reference drugs,
S. aureus was resistant to CEZ, and
Proteus spp.(indole-positive) was resistant to CP, while FRM was highly resisted by almost all strains of bacteria. However, the resistance rate of
S. aureus to CP was relatively low, that is, as low as 16.1%.
5. Since the active concentration of CMX in the tympanum about 1 hour after its administration was estimated to be 2,000-3,000μg/ml, it could be presumed that the bacteria detected from the middle ear secretion which showed MIC≤800μg/ml at the concentration of 10
8CFU/ml was eradicable and that the MIC value and bacteria eradication effect were more highly correlated at the concentration of 10
8CFU/ml than 10
6CFU/ml in case the topical treatment was designed like the present study.
As a result of the above evaluation, CMX, the main ingredient of 1% CMX ototopical solution is quite stable and well balanced at the topically administered concentration, and furthermore, its mode of action or mechanism is selectively toxic to bacteria, while its otic toxicity is considered to be relatively low. From the clinical bacteriological standpoint, therefore, 1% CMX ototopical solution is considered to be a remarkably useful preparation in the clinical field for topical otic use.
View full abstract