This study was conducted to investigate the relationship between the
in vitro susceptibility of the organisms and the outcome of treatment in urinary tract infections. The results achieved in the treatment of 256 patients with acute simple cystitis and 450 patients with complicated urinary tract infections in well controlled study. Summaries were as follows.
1. Clinical response to antibiotic treatment was categorized as either ‘ eradicated ’ or ‘persistent’ by bacteriological response.‘ Replaced ’ was defined as ‘ eradicated ’ when bacteria of identical species to the origin strain were not isolated after treatment.
2. Significant correlations between bacteriological response to treatment and MIC of the given drug to causative organism were obtained in the cases with acute simple cystitis treated with ABPC 1g, 0.5g, and 0.2g daily and in the cases with complicated urinary tract infections.
3. CELs; clinically effective levels, the critical levels of antibiotics which are the minimum necessary to eradicate the urinary organisms, were determined as 209μg/ml, 241μg/ml, and 50μg/ml for the cases with acute simple cystitis treated with ABPC 1g, 0.5g, and 0.2g daily respectively. CELs were determined as 439μg/ml, 79 μg/ml, and 21.8μg/ml for the cases with complicated urinary tract infections treated with CBPC 4g, i. v., CIPC 2g, p. o., and PPA 2g, p. o. daily respectively. The difference in eradication rates of causative organisms in these sensitive and resistant groups was statistically significant.
4. Significant agreement between
in vitro and
in vivo results was obtained despite any host factor influencing the outcome of treatment. In evaluation for differentiation of host factor modifying the bacteriological response, the frequent discrepancy between
in vitro and
in vivo results can't be attributable in the sensitive group. The significantly excellent eradication rate of resistant strains in female cases may be attributed to the differences in characteristics of the causative organisms between male and female cases.
5. The persistency, despite treatment, of sensitive strains in
P. aeruginosa infection and the eradication of resistant strains in indole positive
Proteus spp. infection were observed.
6. No attempt was made to define the relation of urinary concentrations to CEL. But antibacterial activity in the urine was considered as a prerequisite for eradication of bacteria.
7. In investigating the relationship between
in vitro susceptibility and response of urinary organisms to antimicrobial therapy, CEL was considered as more reasonable critical level of urinary tract infections.
View full abstract