A double blind group comparison study was performed to ascertain the efficacy and safety of cefoperasone (CPZ) as compared with cefotiam (CTM).
The following results were obtained:
1. Efficacy: The clinical efficacy rate in postoperative superficial purulent infections (Trial A), were 95.1%(58/61) and 80.8%(42/52) for the CPZ group and CTM groups, respectively. The efficacy rates in postoperative peritonitis and/ or dead space infections (Trial B) were 84.7%(50/59) and 53.7%(29/54) for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively; the CPZ group showed a significantly better results in both trials.
2. Overall improvement: The overall improvement rates at the end of Trial A were 88.9%and10.8% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively; in Trial B they were 81.4% and 57.4% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively. In Trial B, CPZ group showed a significantly better result than the CTM group.
3. Usefulness: In Trial A, usefulness rates as judged by the surgeons were 80.6% and 63.5% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively; in Trial B, the usefulness rates were 71.9% and 38.5% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively. In Trial B, the CPZ group showed a significantly better result than the CTM group.
4. Bacteriology: In Trial A, the eradication rates of clinical isolates were 78.4% and 55.6% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively; in Trial B, the eradication rates were 60.7% and 37.5% for the CPZ and CTM groups, respectively.
5. Side effects: Side effects were noted in 4 cases (2.9%) in the CPZ group and 5 cases (3.9%) in the CTM group. Abnormal labolatory findings were noted in 8 cases treated with CPZ group and 11 cases treated with CTM group. Significant differences were, however, not observed between the two groups, either in kind or frequency of side effect, or in details or frequency of abnormal laboratory findings.
As shown above, CPZ demonstrates superior clinical efficacy and equal safety in comparison with CTM. Based on this we conclude that CPZ is a highly useful antibiotic for the treatment of postoperative infections.
View full abstract