To evaluate objectively the efficacy, safety and usefulness of lomefloxacin (NY-198), a new synthetic quinolone antimicrobial agent, in the treatment of complicated urinary tract infections (UTI), we performed a comparative double-blind trial using norfloxacin (NFLX) as the control drug. Patients were orally administered 600 mg/day of NY-198 (t. i. d.) or 800 mg/day of NFLX (q. i. d.) for five days. The clinical efficacy was evaluated based on the criteria proposed by the Japanese UTI Committee and the following results were obtained.
1. A total of 312 patients (NY-198: 156, NFLX: 156) were treated, among whom clinical efficacy was evaluated in 249 patients (NY-198: 122, NFLX: 127); 63 cases were excluded or dropped out. There was no statistically significant difference in the background charactaristics between the two groups.
2. In the NY-198 group, clinical efficacy assessed by the attending committee was excellent in 36 and moderate in 46 cases, and the efficacy rate (excellent plus good) was 67.2%. In the NFLX group, it was excellent in 47 and moderate in 28 cases and the efficacy rate was 59.1%. There was no signifi cant difference between the two groups.
3. Pyuria was cleared or improved in 52.5% of the patients treated with NY-198 and in 57.5% of the patients with NFLX, with no significant difference between the two groups. As for bacteriological response, the overall eradication rate was 80.6% in the NY-198 group and 73.5% in the NFLX group. For Gram-positive bacteria, the eradication rate was 91.5% in the NY-198 group and 75.3% in the NFLX group, showing a significantly higher rate in the NY-198 group (p<0.01).
4. Clinical efficacy evaluated by doctors was excellent in 36 and moderate in 44 cases, and the efficacy rate was 65.6% in the NT-198 group. In the NFLX group it was excellent in 48 cases, moderate in 25 cases and the efficacy rate was 57.5%. These results were quite similar to those of the committee, and there was no significant difference between the two groups. In the usefulness evaluated by doctors, again no significant difference was observed between the two groups.
5. Side-effects were observed in 7 cases (4.6%) out of 152 in the NY-198 group and 4 cases (2.6%) out of 153 in the NFLX group. Abnormal laboratory findings were noted in 9 cases (7.6%) out of 118 in the NY-198 group and 3 cases (2.4%) out of 127 in the NFLX group. There were no signifi cant differences between the two groups.
From these results, we considered that the therapeutic effect of 600 mg/day of NY-198 (t. i. d.) was the same or greater than that of 800 mg/day of NFLX (q. i. d.) in the treatment of complicated UTI.
View full abstract