We evaluated the efficacy, safety and utility of lomefloxacin (NY-198), a new quinolone antibacterial agent, in the treatment of intrauterine infection or adnexitis (A-group), bartholinitis or Bartholin gland abscess (B-group) by a comparative double-blind method, using bacampicillin (BAPC) as a reference drug.
NY-198 was administered for 7 days at a daily dose of 600 mg (divided into 3 portions) and BAPC for 7 days at a daily dose of 1, 000 mg (divided into 4 portions).
1) Of 219 patients included in this study, 112 received NY-198 and the remaining 107 BAPC.
Sixty-nine patients (NY-198, 34: BAPC, 35) were excluded from the efficacy evaluation and 11 (NY-198, 6: BAPC, 5) from the analysis of adverse reactions. No statistically significant difference was observed between the two groups.
2) The clinical efficacy rate (excellent and good) on the basis of committee judgement was 83.6%(61/73) in the NY-198 group and 81.7%(58/71) in the BAPC group. No statisticallysignificant difference was observed between the two groups.
3) The bacteriological efficacy, evaluated in terms of the eradication rate of isolated organisms, was 88.6%(39/44) for the NY-198 group and 71.9%(23/32) for the BAPC group. Thedifference between the groups was not significant.
4) The overall clinical efficacy rate (excellent and good) for NY-198 and BAPC was 83.6%(61/73) and 81.7%(58/71). No statistically significant difference was observed between the two groups.
5) The clinical improvement rate (markedly improved and improved) according to the doctors in charge was 83.3%(65/78) in the NY-198 group and 87.5%(63/72) in the BAPC group.
As to the A-group diseases, the clinical improvement rate of the NY-198 and BAPC groups was 76.6%(36/47) and 89.1%(41/46).
As to the B-group diseases, the clinical improvement rate of the NY-198 and BAPC groups was 93.5%(29/31) and 84.6%(22/26). There was no statistically significant difference between the two groups.
6) Undesirable symptoms were observed in 5 patients (4.7%) and abnormal changes in laboratory findings in 1 patient (1.0%) in the NY-198 group. Thus no statistically significant difference was observed between the two groups.
7) The utility rate (markedly satisfactory and moderately satisfactory) according to the doctors in c harge was 85.9%(67/78) in the NY-198 group and 87.5%(63/72) in the BAPC group. No statistically significant difference was observed between the two groups.
From these results, we conclude that NY-198 in a daily dose of 600 mg is as effective and useful s BAPC in a daily dose of 1, 000 mg for the treatment of female genital organ infections.
View full abstract