Two experiments were conducted to determine the differences in nutritive values among cattle, sheep and goats fed the same diets. In Exp. 1, animals were fed three low protein diets (5-8% crude protein in dry matter) which consisted of rice straw wafer and some nitrogen supplements. In Exp. 2, animals were fed three diets consisting of hay wafer and concentrate (the ratio of roughage to concentrate, 100: 0, 70: 30 and 30: 70, respectively). Digestion trials were conducted by the total collection method.
1) The digestibility of crude protein (CP) for cattle showed a lower value than that for sheep or goats in Exp. 1 and 2. Differences in digestibility existed for crude fiber (CF) and nitrogen free extracts (NFE) between cattle, goats and sheep in Exp. 1. In Exp. 2, CF and NFE digestibilities for cattle showed higher values than those for sheep and goats.
2) The differences in TDN content were 2-5% between cattle and sheep in Exp. 1 and 1-2 % among cattle, sheep and goats in Exp. 2.
3) Nitrogen excretion in faeces for cattle was higher than that for sheep and goats. Conversely, N excretion in urine for cattle was lower than that for sheep and goats.
4) These results suggest that, species differences reflect differences in digestibilities and nutritive values. The large differences in TDN content between cattle and sheep were found particularly in low protein diets. However, when sheep were fed diets containing more than 10% CP, TDN content rose to the same level as that for cattle. Therefore when the digestibility of rations for cattle was determined via experimentation with sheep, more than 10% CP content was necessary in the diets.
View full abstract