An acute toxicity test for invert soap against Colpod aspera was performed by using monoxenic culture of C. aspera isolated from activated sludge and Alcaligenes faecalis IFO 13111. Four kinds of invert soap were used and those were as follows: benzethonium chloride(BTC), benzalkonium chloride(BKC), didecyl dimethyl ammonium chloride(DAC) and an equally mixed preparation of methyl dodecyl xylilene benzyl ammonium chloride, methyl dodecyl xylilene trimethyl ammonium chloride and polyoxyethylene octyl phenyl ether(MAC
+a). Evaluation of the toxicity was based on the concentration of invert soap at which the specific growth rate of C. aspera was reduced to 50% at 24 hours after the exposure to insert soap(EC
50). EC
50 of BTC, BKC, DAC and MAC
+a were 4.31, 2.89, 1.67 and 3.84 mg/l respectively. It was presumed that in actual application, BTC, BKC, DAC and MAC
+a should be diluted more than 66-, 98-, 47- and 40-fold respectively to reduce the concentrations below EC
50. It was found that DAC produced the highest toxicity against C. aspera and it was followed by BKC, MAC
+a and BTC in the order mentioned. On assessing the safety from the actually applicable concentrations and EC
50, the highest safety was demonstrated by MAC
+a followed by DAC, BTC and BKC.
View full abstract