ジェンダー史学
Online ISSN : 1884-9385
Print ISSN : 1880-4357
ISSN-L : 1880-4357
最新号
選択された号の論文の7件中1~7を表示しています
特集論文
  • ――サンディ・ストーン「帝国の逆襲」を再読する――
    藤高 和輝
    2025 年21 巻 p. 7-17
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    In this article, I consider the difficulty of discussing transgender history through a rereading of Sandy Stoneʼ s pioneering article “The Empire Strikes Back: A Posttranssexual Manifesto.” Her article traces the history in which “transsexuals” were colonialized as the object of knowledge and argues for the importance of a strategy in which “transsexuals” speak for themselves as the subject of knowledge, that is, according to her term, “posttranssexuals.” Rereading her article is important now because of the difficulty and need to speak about the experience and existence of transgender people as differently reiterated in the present. Indeed, the contemporary trans-exclusionary discourse attacks transgender people and erases their real voices and lives. In this sense, we are confronted with a situation similar to that which Stone faced. Thus, my rereading of her article indicates the difficulty and necessity of speaking about transgender history, or transgender itself. To further our understanding, we need to confirm in detail the historical context in which Stoneʼ s article was written. And, at the same time, it is important to make clear the similarity between the contemporary situation transgender people face and the situation at the time Stone wrote “The Empire Strikes Back.” In the end, this article argues that rereading Stoneʼ s article provides significant ideas for a rethinking of transgender history and empowers us to make a counter-discourse to resist transphobia.

  • ――「性同一性障害特例法」をめぐって
    吉野 靫
    2025 年21 巻 p. 19-31
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    This paper explores the long-term social and emotional effects of Japanʼ s GID (Gender Identity Disorder) Special Law through the narrative of an AFAB (Assigned Female At Birth) transgender person who lived with a male presentation but a female legal status for over 15 years. Their account reveals how institutional conditions, peer dynamics, and normative expectations surrounding gender transition shaped deeply personal decisions about identity, body, and legality. They first encountered the concept of gender transition through media coverage of surgery and television dramas. Although they gradually adopted a masculine appearance, they refrained from undergoing surgery for many years, navigating social life with a visible gender incongruity. They describe how the gap between legal status and appearance affected job prospects and everyday interactions, especially as others around them began changing their legal gender through surgery. They eventually changed their legal gender in 2023, after the Supreme Court of Japan invalidated the sterilization requirement. While relieved, they also expressed guilt toward peers who had undergone irreversible procedures out of necessity under the prior legal regime. Their testimony highlights what they call a “harsh binary of choice”—either conform to a medicalized, state-approved path or live with continued systemic disadvantage. This case exemplifies the tension produced by rigid legal frameworks. It also demonstrates how legal systems can impose lasting emotional consequences—both on those denied access and on those who complied with unjust requirements.

特集寄稿
  • 三橋 順子
    2025 年21 巻 p. 33-42
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    This article presents the personal reflections of a historian who not only specializes in the study of gender transgression but is also a gender transgressor myself. The first section outlines two fundamental understandings of gender transgression, five associated roles or functions, and the concept of “double gender”̶a principle in which possessing characteristics of both genders is perceived as the source of a unique, extraordinary ability distinct from that of the average person. The second section recounts how the author first became interested in the phenomenon of gender transgression and began my research journey approximately forty years ago. The third section describes the development of my interdisciplinary methodology, which̶while grounded in historical analysis of written, oral, and visual sources̶also incorporates insights from sociology, cultural anthropology, folklore studies, and geography, ultimately leading to an approach unconstrained by periodization or regional boundaries. The fourth section reflects on the encounters with two scholars that prompted me to reengage with the field of history after having nearly departed from it. The fifth section shifts focus to offer a critique of the current state of Japanese historiography from the perspective of a researcher in gender and sexuality history. The author highlights several issues, including the uncritical retrojection of modern concepts (e.g., “homosexuality” ), the reductive reinforcement of the gender binary, and the relatively underdeveloped state of sexuality history in comparison to gender history. In the final section, the author offers a "testament" to the Japanese historical profession. I argue that rigid conceptions of gender̶based on the binary of men and women̶and of sexuality̶limited to heterosexual relations̶continue to dominate Japanese historiography. In this respect, the discipline lags behind adjacent fields. This delay is not merely a matter of research focus; historians must also acknowledge the presence of sexual minorities within their own ranks. Embracing the principles of DEI (diversity, equity, and inclusion) and cultivating a pluralistic understanding of gender and sexuality, the author contends, is essential for constructing a richer and more inclusive historical imagination.

  • 岡田 実穂
    2025 年21 巻 p. 43-51
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    This paper explores the structural burdens placed on LGBTIQA+ survivors of sexual assault in Japan through demands to be visible, to speak, and to serve as symbols of legitimacy. Drawing from over two decades of activist practice and lived experience, I reflect on how social and legal systems have required survivors to disclose personal trauma in exchange for recognition, often reinforcing stigma and exclusion rather than dismantling it. Based in northern Japan, Broken Rainbow Japan has developed a range of initiatives̶from policy advocacy and legal reform to community support spaces and expressive projects̶designed to challenge these dynamics. In particular, we consider the limits of “voice” as a condition of inclusion and the risks faced by those whose identities and narratives do not conform to dominant expectations. The work of the late Shoko Usami, who stood at the intersection of multiple marginalized identities, becomes central in understanding how art, silence, and alternative modes of expression can also be forms of resistance and survival. Even after legal progress, including reforms to Japan’ s Penal Code in 2017 and 2023, social recognition and institutional support remain uneven. This paper calls for a shift away from individual sacrifice as a requirement for systemic change, and toward a framework where diverse experiences and expressions can be held without demanding performative legibility. By grounding this critique in rural activism, survivor-led advocacy, and intergenerational memory, I argue for a more just and sustainable form of queer anti-assault organizing̶one in which no one must stand alone to be heard.

論文
  • ――「変生男子」言説にみるセックス/ジェンダー観――
    田中 亜以子
    2025 年21 巻 p. 53-67
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    This study investigates how sexual difference was understood in early modern Japan and examines the relationship between such understandings and the organization of society based on binary sex distinctions. Specifically, it focuses on the discourse surrounding henjo nanshi—a term used throughout the early modern period in reference to cases of physical transformation from female to male. By analyzing how bodily transformation was understood, how actual cases were treated within society, and the distinction between gendered attributes which were considered to change “naturally” versus those that required “social” reclassification, the study sheds light on the interplay between body, gender, and social order. Three major findings emerge from the analysis. First, while such transformations were regarded as extremely rare, male and female bodies were often understood as two mutable forms of a single body, implying a belief in the fluidity of physical sex. Second, when transformations involving genitalia occurred, state authorities assessed the morphology of the genitals to determine the individualʼs legal and social sex, thereby reinforcing a binary gender order. Notably, transformations from female to male were celebrated as auspicious, reaffirming a hierarchical framework in which masculinity was privileged over femininity. Third, individuals who underwent such changes were required to alter their hairstyle, clothing, name, and occupational role in accordance with their newly assigned gender. At the same time, it was acknowledged that some gendered characteristics regarding temperament and behavior also underwent spontaneous, “natural” transformation along with the physical changes. These findings suggest that early modern Japanese society, structured by a rigid status system, maintained a complex duality: a view of the body as inherently fluid coexisted with a strict binary model of gender. This means that even without asserting the essential nature of physical sexual differences, the gender-based social structure remained stable. Nonetheless, the close association of masculinity and femininity with bodily form suggests that socially prescribed gender roles were understood to exist within a loose continuum that included “natural” sex differences.

  • 牧野 雅子
    2025 年21 巻 p. 69-83
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    This paper examines the emergence of the policewoman system in Japan and its historical context, tracing developments from the prewar to postwar periods in relation to the evolution of the national police system. Even before World War II, women were engaged in certain police-related duties, and the idea of employing female police officers was occasionally considered̶particularly in response to crimes involving women. Following Japan’ s defeat in the war, the democratization of the police was promoted by the General Headquarters (GHQ). Anticipating this reform, the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department took the initiative to recruit female officers in an effort to soften the public image of the police and present a more democratic appearance. The recruitment of women police officers attracted many applicants who wished to contribute to society. The first policewomen were hired by the Tokyo Metropolitan Police Department in March 1946. These women were assigned to visible roles such as street patrols and desk duties. They were celebrated by the media as symbols of democratization, gender equality, and the advancement of women in society. However, despite being called “policewomen,” they were not given the status of police officers, and their actual duties were limited to traffic control, juvenile guidance, and administrative tasks. Over time, the recruitment of female officers expanded nationwide, and their roles and status gradually improved. Nevertheless, once the democratization process was considered complete, restrictions on their duties and legal status were reinstated, and the significance of their presence within the police force diminished. This suggests that although policewomen were publicly portrayed as symbols of gender equality and reform, in practice they were used to support and reinforce the male-dominated structure of the police organization.

研究ノート
  • ――ンタガンダ事件判決を素材として――
    中澤 登水子
    2025 年21 巻 p. 85-93
    発行日: 2025/10/13
    公開日: 2026/10/13
    ジャーナル フリー

    On March 30, 2021, the International Criminal Court (ICC) Appeals Chamber confirmed Bosco Ntagandaʼs conviction for crimes, including sexual crimes, committed in the Democratic Republic of the Congo (DRC). This study argues that this judgment is significant in gender history for two reasons: first, that the Court, a permanent institution, has upheld a conviction for sexual violence, and second, that the Chamber recognized sexual violence as part of a “common plan” of core crimes, namely, genocide, crimes against humanity, and war crimes. Until now, international criminal justice has attempted to attribute responsibility not to individual perpetrators, but to higher-ranking leaders of organizations who are considered to bear greater responsibility. The concept of a “common plan” is useful in pursing the responsibility of masterminds as principals. However, ad hoc tribunals have treated sexual violence as an individual deviant and opportunistic act that falls outside plans or policies. This understanding of sexual violence does not contradict the traditional view that “it is something any man would do.” This view is not unrelated to the culture of impunity that expects victims to tolerate it. Therefore, the judgment in this case is important. This study is structured as follows: First, it provides an overview of the ICC and previous cases related to sexual crimes that have been brought before it. Second, it reviews the facts and trial processes of the Ntaganda case and clarifies the verdictʼs significance. Third, it draws lessons from the Ntaganda case and examines the relationship between the “common plan” and sexual violence, using the alleged crimes against individuals for whom arrest warrants have recently been issued as material.

feedback
Top