Kyomachiya (traditional wooden townhouses) are one of the important elements characterizing the historical urban landscape of Kyoto. However, the rapid decrease in the number of
kyomachiya and the modern urban landscape filled with high-rise buildings constructed after
kyomachiya demolitions have been controversial. In recent years, the preservation of
kyomachiya has become an urgent policy issue.
This paper examines the determinants of the demolition of
kyomachiya in the Nishijin district, one of the historical town centers of Kyoto. We used the results of
kyomachiya facade surveys to conduct stepwise logistic regression analysis incorporating explanatory variables of three categories related to
kyomachiya demolitions and land use changes: 1) characteristics (conditions and usage) of
kyomachiya; 2) land use restrictions; and 3) neighborhood conditions (percentage of
kyomachiya, high-rise buildings, and other land use types within a 25-m or 50-m radius).
The examination of
kyomachiya demolitions shows that 13% of the
kyomachiya in the Nishijin district were demolished from 1998 to 2004, approximately 60% of demolished
kyomachiya were rebuilt into modern townhouses, and 15% were transformed into apartment houses or commercial buildings. The spatial distribution of the demolitions was bipolarized: the ratio of demolitions was higher in areas where the density was lower, and vice versa.
The results of binary logistic regression analysis show that the demolitions are determined by building type (detached/terraced), building conditions, vacancy, building height restriction, and neighborhood conditions. In addition,
kyomachiya demolitions are negatively related to neighborhood conditions. The spatial extents of neighborhood conditions differ by land use type. We discuss the demolition of one
kyomachiya induces another demolition due to the neighborhood effect. Therefore, it can lead to a spatially bipolarized pattern of demolitions. Further analysis based on multinomial logistic regression analysis shows that land use changes after demolitions are determined by land use restrictions, neighborhood conditions, and previous
kyomachiya characteristics. In particular, detached and well-maintained
kyomachiya located within a semi-industrial zone and in neighborhoods where the density of
kyomachiya is already low are more likely to be transformed into modern townhouses.
We conclude that, in a neighborhood where the number of
kyomachiya is relatively low, the speed of
kyomachiya demolitions increases locally so that the spatial pattern of the demolitions will be biased. Land use types after the demolitions are influenced by land use restrictions and neighborhood conditions as well as previous usages and conditions of
kyomachiya. Therefore, the process of land use changes from
kyomachiya occurs with both spatial and temporal linkages.
View full abstract