Historia Scientiarum. Second Series: International Journal of the History of Science Society of Japan
Online ISSN : 2436-9020
Print ISSN : 0285-4821
Volume 34, Issue 2
Displaying 1-7 of 7 articles from this issue
Special Issue Science Wars Before the “Science Wars”: East Asia as Method
Articles
  • Hansun HSIUNG
    2025Volume 34Issue 2 Pages 168-196
    Published: April 25, 2025
    Released on J-STAGE: October 06, 2026
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    This article examines Nishi Amane’s 1874 “Discourse on Knowledge,” positioning it as a key theorization of the meaning of “modern science” (科學) and thus a key—albeit forgotten—text in the genealogy of Japanese science studies (科学論). Science, for Nishi, was a “war of the intellect.” As a war, it required strategies for the rational management of resources and infrastructure. Science overall thus became “modern” by becoming the object of planning by experts in the social sciences specifically. However, creating such experts required breaking from prior Neo-Confucian frameworks which took the act of knowing nature as a process of transforming individual moral subjectivity. On this basis, I make two contentions. First, I argue that the concept of “modern science” in Japan was defined less by changes internal to the natural sciences themselves, and more by the renegotiation of the meaning of Confucian techniques of governance relative to new social sciences. Second, I suggest that the rupture of moral subjectivity inaugurated by Nishi is a crucial, unresolved thread of science studies in Japan.

    Download PDF (436K)
  • Sean Hsiang-lin LI
    2025Volume 34Issue 2 Pages 197-224
    Published: April 25, 2025
    Released on J-STAGE: October 06, 2026
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    The present article first offers a revisionist account of Tianyan lun 天演論 (On Heavenly Evolution), Yan Fu’s 嚴復 (1854–1921) 1898 translation of Thomas Huxley’s Evolution and Ethics (1893). While Tianyan lun is widely recognized as one of the most influential books in modern Chinese thought, it is little acknowledged that Yan Fu constructed within it a theory of civilization by creating the twin concepts of zhihua 治化 and zhigong 治功 to translate the modern notion of civilization into Chinese. With this new understanding, the opposition Yan Fu posed between two competing visions for reforming China—Civilization and Ti-yong 體用 (Essence-Function)—emerged as a defining and consequential tension. For Yan, the crux lies in contrasting stances toward Western civilization: one advocating its adoption as a unified entity embodying universality; and the other, exemplified by Zhang Zhidong’s 張之洞 (1837–1909) official doctrine of Essence-Function, rejecting such a holistic and universalist conception.

    This central stake explains why a fundamental—but largely unrecognized—“science war” over the proper conceptions of science and technology lies at the heart of the tension between the two reform visions. In challenging the doctrine of Essence-Function, Yan repudiated Zhang’s concept of yi 藝,which roughly referred to mechanical arts or technology. By prioritizing technology over science, yi represents an unusual resistance to the two-century-long Western consensus that science takes precedence. As Yan’s theory of civilization relies on science to ensure the universality and holism of Western civilization, he drew on a Neo-Confucian framework to construct a concept of science as “Western gezhi” 西學格致,advancing the revolutionary argument that “science is the foundation of Western institutions.”

    By making this “science war” visible, this article foregrounds the role of science and technology in the enduring tension between China’s two historical approaches to engaging with the universalist and holistic characterization of Western civilization—an issue later framed as modernity and universal values, and one that remains more urgent than ever today. In this light, the emergence of compound terms denoting “science-technology,” namely kexue-jishu 科學技術 and keji 科技,in the 1950s—predating the concept of technoscience in Western science studies—may have originated from this unresolved tension and merit further investigation.

    Download PDF (433K)
  • Menglan CHEN
    2025Volume 34Issue 2 Pages 225-256
    Published: April 25, 2025
    Released on J-STAGE: October 06, 2026
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    Amid China’s New Culture Movement, a campaign that sought to enlighten the nation with “Mr. Science,” a spiritualist-divinatory group claimed success in photographing immortal spirits. For the spiritualists, these photographs provided undeniable evidence of the immortals’ existence, thereby legitimizing lingxue (靈學), the scientific study of the numinous. This article examines the epistemological significance of lingxue by looking at how lingxue practitioners re-imagined photography’s object, semiotics, and instrumentality. For them, immortal spirit photography captured lingguang 靈光, or numinous light, whose shape and intensity indexed a spirit’s position on a cosmic moral spectrum. Situating this practice at the intersection of the spectrum theory of light, religious worldviews, global spiritualism, and the translingual study of the numinous (ling/rei 靈) in East Asia, I show how lingxue understood seeing and knowing as extension of one’s moral selfhood. Immortal spirit photography thus charted an epistemological stance that was easily dismissed during the two “science wars” in modern China. Both the 1918–1919 “Debunking lingxue” polemic and the 1923–1924 “Science and Metaphysics” debate focused on defending the boundaries of modern science rather than questioning its epistemic claims. In contrast, immortal spirit photography posited what I call “the epistemology of the spectral,” which problematized the mechanical objectivity and linear temporality of photography as a central instrument of modern science. Instead, it reframed the camera as a morally sensitive medium, anticipating the becoming of a new self. In doing so, it offered a broader critique of the epistemic violence of modernization, lamenting the unfinished transformation of the knowing subject as the unfinished project of the Chinese enlightenment.

    Download PDF (1468K)
  • Yasuhiro OKAZAWA
    2025Volume 34Issue 2 Pages 257-287
    Published: April 25, 2025
    Released on J-STAGE: October 06, 2026
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    In the Japanese Empire’s “science wars” from the late 1930s to 1945, Kyoto School philosopher of science Shimomura Toratarō waged war on the Eurocentric historiography of science. Unlike today’s global historians of science who seek to document non-Western scientific contributions, Shimomura showed little interest in Japan’s scientific achievements before its modernization. He even readily accepted the European origins of “modern science.” His critique of the conventional history of science instead targeted Europe’s exclusive ownership of the historical narrative, which, in his view, stemmed from a misunderstanding that assumed historians were already equipped with a fully developed concept of science. To challenge this narrative, Shimomura proposed a new historiography called “history toward science.” This approach recast science as being in a state of becoming, with its trajectory punctuated by “world-historical events”—each introducing new ways of reasoning and reconceptualizing science. Shifting his focus from first-order knowledge production to a second-order theorization of science, Shimomura’s history toward science remained open to the possibility of another event that might dramatically reshape the concept of science. Shimomura regarded “backward” actors in knowledge production as having theoretical advantages because their experiences of assimilating foreign epistemic techniques forced them to deeply reflect on the nature of science. This opened up the possibility for backward actors, specifically Japan, to become leading figures in the theorization of future science. He envisioned a distant future in which a pluralist conception of science would take shape, embracing every cultural group as a meaningful contributor. Conceiving of science as a key basis for creating the common world, his pluralist world history of science was strikingly aligned with the Japanese Empire’s supposedly pluralist world-making, ultimately leading him to embrace the problematic “Greater East Asian War.” Shimomura’s original yet dangerous history toward science offers a powerful anti-Eurocentric critique of the global history of science, which highlights the conception of science and the act of narration as key topics for further scrutiny. It in turn reveals the unsettling affinity between the global history of science and global imperialism.

    Download PDF (508K)
  • Jaehwan HYUN
    2025Volume 34Issue 2 Pages 288-314
    Published: April 25, 2025
    Released on J-STAGE: October 06, 2026
    JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

    The cultural wars during the Cold War have already drawn the attention of historians, particularly regarding the different ways the concept of science was framed by the communist and capitalist regimes. This paper contributes to this literature by exploring how Chosŏn Korea’s Confucian scholar, Choe Han-Gi (崔漢綺,1803–1879) and his work were interpreted differently by philosophers in North and South Korea during the 1960s. Specifically, it examines how philosophers related Choe’s theory, known as the Learning of Qi (氣學), to Western science. Despite apparent contradictions in North and South Korean philosophers’ views of Choe Han-Gi, there were more commonalities and connections than conflicts. This paper shows how during the late 1950s and early 1960s, philosophers in both Koreas initiated research on Choe Han-Gi in response to their respective postcolonial attempts to address Chuch’esŏng (主體性), which can be roughly translated as subjectivity, independence, or self-reliance. Both countries’ philosophers were concerned with establishing foundations for modern science within their respective national contexts, and they sought to present Choe Han-gi and his work as a historical example of scientific indigeneity. I argue that Kim Cheol-Ang (金哲央,b. 1929), a Zainichi Korean (在日朝鮮人) philosopher, played a critical role in advancing and mediating philosophical research on Choe Han-Gi across the politically divided peninsula, contributing to there being greater similarities in the arguments of both Koreas. However, his mediating role was not acknowledged by the philosophical communities in either country. Ultimately, while the geopolitical rivalry between capitalist and socialist conceptions of science did not result in a cultural war, Zainichi scholars were subjected to epistemic violence through the systematic erasure of their contributions.

    Download PDF (518K)
News
feedback
Top