Case
The case was a 58-year-old male patient who suffered from dysphagia, organic articulation disorders, trismus, and severe nasality after surgery for hard palate cancer (rpT4bN2cM0).
Methods
Rehabilitation for dysphagia and organic articulation disorders was achieved by a speech therapist (ST) according to the physician’s prescription. Three appliances ― (i) an interim denture, (ii) an obturator, and (iii) a nasal speaking valve (NSV) ― were fabricated during the rehabilitation period.
Functional assessments were performed ― the speech intelligibility test, the Japanese 100-monosyllable intelligibility test, a nasometer test, a repetitive saliva-swallowing test, a modified water-swallowing test ― and a questionnaire for the three appliances was administered.
Results and Discussion
With the interim denture prosthesis, the speech intelligibility score was 2 and the monosyllable intelligibility score was 32.4%. Although swallowing, nasality, and speech improved with this appliance, nasal reflux remained, and the appliance could be worn only for a limited time.
With the obturator prosthesis, the speech intelligibility score was 2 and the monosyllable intelligibility score was 39%. Swallowing, nasality, and difficulty in speech were improved. With this appliance, nasal reflux was not observed.
With the NSV, the speech intelligibility score was 2.8 and the monosyllable intelligibility score was 33.4. Although nasality and speech improved without discomfort, the patient did not use the NSV when eating. The NSV could be worn for longer periods for daily activities because of its convenience in handling.
The three appliances were preferably used in different situations, i.e., the interim denture during eating at home, the obturator during eating and talking outdoors, particularly in noisy surroundings, and the NSV during speech.
From this case, it is suggested that the concept of selecting rehabilitation appliances according to their purpose during daily life may be useful for improving the patient’s quality of life.
View full abstract