In this research, I have two aims:
(1) Are there differences for viewpoints of whole by changing the numbers of parts which construct whole?
(2) When two quantities relate to "double and half" for "part-whole", can pupils deal with relations? In view of two aims, I have carried out the investigation for 5 Lottery Problems. The investigation was carried out in the second term.
The subjects are 5th grade pupils (N=63) of two elementary schools in Kobe and Himeji. They aren't taught ratio in this term. They are divided two group [Experimental Group (N=32) and Control Group (N=31)] by difference in the numbers of parts which construct whole. The following ploblems of Experimental Group and Control Group were carried out:
Question of Experimental Group.
There are the A box and the B box with red marbles, blue marbles and white marbles, respectively.
The A box has P red marbles, Q blue marbles and R white marbles.
The B box has S red marbles, T blue marbles and U white marbles.
Which box will have a greater chance of drawing a blue marble?
(1) Please mark the one among 3 choices.
A box will have a greater chance. Both boxes will have the same chance. B box will have a greater chance.
[figure]
(2) Why?
Question of Control Group.
There are the A box and the B box with red marbles and white marbles, respectively.
The A box has X red marbles and Y white marbles.
The B box has Z red marbles and W white marbles.
Which box will have a greater chance of drawing a white marble?
(X=P+R, Y=Q, Z=S+U, W=T)
As results of analyses, I have clarified the following contents.
(1) There are differences for viewpoints of whole by changing the numbers of parts which construct whole.
(2) When two quantities relate to "double and half" for "part-whole", pupils can't deal with relations.
抄録全体を表示