Seventy-three patients with squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck were treated with radiotherapy at Tokyo Women's Medical College from 1968 until 1985. The 135 metastatic cervical lymph nodes were given radiation doses exceeding TDF 65 (40 Gy/20 fr/4 weeks). The data was analyzed retrospectively to evaluate the factors affecting radiation response and control. 1) At 1 month following radiotherapy, the complete response (CR) rate was 102/135 (76%), partial response (PR) was 23/135 (17%), 6/135 (4%) registered no change (NC), and 4/135 (3%) exhibited progressive disease (PD). 2) The CR rate for nodes near the primary site was 65/68 (96%) for nasopharynx, 12/15 (80%) oropharynx, 13/21 (62%) for hypopharynx, 0/7 for tongue, 8/17 (47%) for larynx, and 4/7 for maxillary sinus, respectively. 3) The CR rate was 81/98 (83%) for lymph nodes up to 3 cm compared to 21/37 (58%) for larger nodes. In nasopharyngeal carcinoma, the CR rate for nodes up to 3 cm was 30/30 (100%) at dose levels over TDF 65; however, for larger nodes, it was 4/7 (57%) at TDF 65-99 and 10/10 (100%) at TDF 100 or above. In other carcinomas, the CR rate for nodes up to 3 cm was 13/23 (57%) at 65-99 and 17/24 (71%) at TDF 100 or ab ove; however, for larger nodes, it was 0/2 at TDF 65-99 and 7/18 (39%) at TDF 100 or above. 4) In moderately and well differentiated carcinomas, the CR rate was related to TDF. 5) In follow-up studies, 8 of 102 CR nodes recurred and were accompanied by primary and/or distant disease; 5 out of 23 PR nodes changed to CR 2-12 months after treatment. 6) The 2-year CR rate for nasopharyngeal carcinoma nodes was 19/28 (68%) and 15/42 (36%) in the other nodes. The data suggests that, for patients with metastatic lymph nodes from squamous cell carcinoma of the head and neck, radiotherapy was effective and useful in curing nodes up to 3 cm, irrespective ofth e primary site or histological grade. However, with the exception of nasopharyngeal carcinoma, multimodal treatment should be considered for nodes larger than 3cm.
View full abstract