OBJECTIVE: To report the therapeutic results of preoperative irradiation using acombination of external irradiation and high dose rate intraluminal irradiation using
60Co aimed at enhancing postoperative local control of advanced rectal cancer.
MATERIALS AND METHODS: The subjects comprised 38 patients (RT group: 31 men and 7 women ranging in age from 26-77 years; mean 61.2 years; tumor site RaRb 10, Rb 22, RbP 6) in whom≥A
l'lower rectal cancer was suspected and who under went preoperative irradiation at this hospital. A control group (N-RT group) consisted of 16 patients (11 men and 5 women, age 31-76 years; mean 59.9 years; tumor site RaRb 4, Rb 10, RbP 2) subjected to operation alone in whom clinical≥A
1' and postoperative histological study revealed≥a
1. The pre-irradiation biopsy diagnosis in all cases was adenocarcinoma except 2 cases with negative cancer cells. Intraluminal irradiation was performed using a balloon applicator developed to maximize the radiation dose to the tumor portion and minimize it to the extent possible to the unaffected portions, delivering 30-40 Gy/3-4 Fr (dose evaluation point set at 1.0, 1.5 or 2.0 cm from the source). The external irradiation was performed with a 10 MVX delivering 30-40 Gy/15-20 Fr to the entire pelvic cavity (upper margin being the upper edge of L5 and lower margin the lower edge of the ischium). After a mean waiting period of 13.9 days after irradiation, abdominoperineal resection (APR) was performed in 34 cases and low anterior resection (LAR) in four. In the N-RT group the surgical procedure was APR in 10 cases and LAR in six.
RESULTS: Using the criteria of Ohboshi and Shimozato to judge the histopathological effect, no cases showed Grade I, while of Grade II, 15 cases showed IIA and 19 cases IIB, Grade III in 4 cases. Grade IIB or above was noted in 23 of 38 (61%).
Five and 8-year survival rates were 82.5 and 82.5% in the RT group, and were 79.5 and 79. 5% in the N-RT group. Although these differences were not significant, a trend to better survival was found in the RT group. The local recurrence rate was 8%(3/38 cases) in the RT group in contrast to 25%(4/16 cases) in the N-RT group. The following complications developed during radiation therapy: diarrhea 19 (50%), anal pain 18 (47%), pollakisuria 3 (8%), anal erosion 2 (5%), and herpes zoster 2 (5%), but did not require premature termination of the therapy in any case. Postoperative complications consisted of perineal fluid collection 4 (10%), bowel obstruction 3 cases (8%), an anastomotic insufficiency 3 (8%), fistula formation of bladder 2 (5%), ureteral narrowing 1 (3%), and thrombosis of vein 1 cases (3%) of the RT group, while perineal fluid collection 1 (6%), bowel obstruction 1 (6%), an anastomotic insufficiency 4 (25%) of the N-RT group, only one case of RT group (3%) required surgical treatment for the fistula formation of bladder.
CONCLUSION: Although a significant enhancement of the survival rate was not achieved by preoperative radiotherapy with external plus intraluminal irradiation for advanced lower rectal cancer, this treatment contributed to excellent local control and a decrease and distant metastasis rate.
View full abstract