The incidence of right vocal fold paralysis is lower than that occurring on the left. The higher incidence of left vocal fold paralysis can perhaps be explained by the fact that a greater portion of the recurrent nerve is located on the left. The current study focused on the characteristics of and surgical approaches taken in cases of vocal fold paralysis that occurs on the right side.
Of the 110 patients with unilateral vocal fold paralysis who received surgical therapy at Isshiki Clinic : Kyoto Voice Surgical Center between 1994 and 2006, 35 (22 males and 13 females ; ages ranging from 17 to 75 years, with a mean of 49.4) with paralysis on the right side were selected. The causes for paralysis were : thyroid surgery (16 cases), surgery for cervical vagus neurinoma (5), idiopathic paralysis (3), surgery for neurinoma of the mediastinal vagus nerve (3), brain tumor (3) and surgery for esophageal cancer, head injury, and surgery of the cervical vertebrae (one each).
For surgical procedures, arytenoid adduction (AA) was employed for cases with a wide glottic slit and thyroplasty type 1 (type 1) for those with a narrow glottic slit. When the glottic slit was wide with atrophy, AA was combined with type 1. The vocal folds were shifted medially to those undergoing AA, type 1 or AA + type 1, and we tried cricothyroid approximation testing. For the 10 patients who exhibited voice improvement, thyroplasty type 4 (type 4) was added. It was suspected that the background conditions of paralysis resulted in insufficient functioning of the cricothyroid muscle in these 10 patients. To evaluate the voice before and after surgery, maximum phonation time (MPT) and the AD/DC ratio were determined.
The postoperative MPT improved in all except for one case whose test results were unchanged. The AC/DC ratio also increased in all except one.
When failure of the cricothyroid muscle is suspected in cases of unilateral vocal fold paralysis, correcting the glottic slit is not sufficient ; tension should be added to the vocal fold in the anterior and posterior directions. First, the vocal fold is shifted medially by applying AA, type 1 or AA + type 1 ; then, having monitored the patient's voice, a combination with type 4 should be considered as an intra-operative option.
View full abstract