We retrospectively investigated recurrent cases of papillary thyroid carcinomas (PTCs) to find appropriate modes of neck dissection for PTCs. One hundred twenty-nine patients with thyroid cancer received surgical treatment at the department from 1987 to 1998, and 110 patients (29 males, 81 females) with papillary thyroid carcinomas were available for the present study. In our clinic, jugular modified neck dissection or modified radical neck dissection were applied, if jugular nodes were prominent in preoperative images, or if they proved to be metastatic lymph nodes in an intraoperative pathological study. Thus, jugular modified neck dissections were performed in 13 cases, and modified radical neck dissections, in 29 cases. In the remaining 68 cases, the ranges of dissections were within regional lymph nodes, or no lymph nodes were dissected.
Recurrence in jugular nodes occurred in 3 of 68 cases without jugular node dissection. Extra-capsular invasions at the primary lesions were observed in all of the 3 cases.
Metastases in lateral neck lymph nodes were present in 6 of 29 cases with radical modified neck dissection. In 5 of these 6 cases, swellings of the lymph nodes had been detected in preoperative images or by palpation.
The overall ten-year survival rate as determined by the Kaplan-Meier method as 94.4% over the entire series.
We consider that the application of jugular node dissection may be extended to patients with extra-capsular invasion at the primary lesion. We also conclude that lateral neck dissections should be performed if swellings of the lymph nodes are detected in preoperative study.
抄録全体を表示