The term brain death has several connotations. From the historical aspect, the original concept of brain death was possibly a vague idea that the central nervous system, including the spinal cord, had sustained irreversible functional loss. Then, the functional cessation of the entire brain in the cranial vault was regarded as brain death. This whole brain death means that the entire brain, including the brainstem and the cerebellum, is dead. Brainstem death, which was advocated soon after, means that the brainstem is dead whether the cerebrum is dead or alive. Throughout this synoptic history, the concept of brain death has been based only on considerations of clinical neurology. The main reason for brain death being exclusively clinical is that autopsy findings vary from almost normal tissue brain to the so-called “respirator brain”. However, from the pathological viewpoint focused on the early stage of autolysis, especially foamy changes in red blood cells, the cessation of blood flow occurs at least in the brainstem by the time the judgement of brain death is made and this event is considered to be the beginning of absolute irreversible changes. Therefore the concept of brain death proves to be pathophysiological as well as clinical and the concept of brainstem death is also essential. Solitary brainstem death, in which the cerebrum is still alive is induced on rare occasions in which supratentorial perfusion pressure is maintained, for instance, by ventricular drainage. The results of blood flow studies, electrophysiological examinations, and so on, performed on brain dead patients all correspond to the above definition of solitary brainstem death. The death of the brain results in that of the body biologically. The concept of brain death established on the basis of these pathophysiological criteria will contribute to the intimately related controversial proposition that a philosophy, with complex but conceptually distinguishable components, that is to say, the biological entity and the person as a human being, be established
View full abstract