This paper attempts to re-examine the concept of community, based on narratives on "ties" expressed by the second-generation Maghrebi-French living in the banlieue of Paris. The formal discourse of the French Republic reads that the "social ties of citizens" bound to "social contracts" between individuals, who do not differ from one another in the "public space", should be the only correct form of community. The French "of colour" including Maghrebi-French, however, are being visualised as an "ethnic community" violating "public space". These double-edged definitions of communities also shape the reality of people's lives, especially in the changing and organising of the maghrebin's living spaces. In this paper, I analyse the narratives of second-generation Maghrebi-French, who literally speak of "our community" and "I am out of our community", and their spatial practices. The Maghrebin moved from bidonville, the slum, to habitations a loyer modere (HLM), the social collective housing, in the banlieue, according to an integration policy. They were to settle in an urban space, with each of their houses to be used as a mould for shaping a socially normalised life and to form family units where people with diverse origins, as "individuals", were to enjoy the "social mixture", as opposed to forming an "ethnic community". At that time the peripheral HLM zone, cite, discoursed as a zone for immigrant families, was described as "a ghettoising zone to display the communal difference" detached from the social ties between citizens. Yet, now, those zones are marginalised as places still to be "civil-ised", where we find a vision for an "ethnic community without a distinction between public and private" and people who are visualised as marginalised citizens. Having clarified these points, I analyse the narratives and spatial practices of Maghrebi-French living in the banlieue of Paris where and with whom I conducted my fieldwork. In my analysis, I use Marc Auge's concept of "non-place/place" and Michel de Certeau's "space" as the place of practice for the keys to my discussion. With the "space" where people carry out face-to-face relations in the city as an anonymous "non-place" as my central concer, I analyse the "ties" of the second-generation Maghrebi-French to clarify the shape of the living and lived community. Each of the self-representational narratives of the second-generation Maghrebi-French tries to define them in the image of French citizens, differentiating themselves from their parents and alienating "the culture of the community of one's origin". The narratives, at the same time, refer to the communities as practical face-to-face relations in their living spaces. Therefore, I first examine their narrative of "our 'ties'". As a part of their life histories, they narrated the story of their movement from bidonville to HLM as their "deracinated" experience from their "own community". Through my analysis, I indicate that there is a practice to define the limited living space of bidonville as "our territory", on one hand, and schools and spaces shared with their French friends as the "outside" world of the former, on the other hand. Also, I point out that the mixed nature of "our community" which was formed within the "closed space" through their interfacial relations with neighbours and friends in "compatoriotic" relationships. Then, I discuss how this community is different from the homogeneous "ethnic community". Secondly, defining the mixed space of HLM as a "non-place" since it is narrated as a "closed and not mixing relation,
(View PDF for the rest of the abstract.)
View full abstract