This paper discusses the basic structure of religious practices at a Chinese temple in Singapore, paying particular attention to the relationship between the secular caretaker known as the "chairman" with the religious professionals, Daoist priests, and Tang-ki spirit mediums. The paper begins its discussion with the assumption that the Daoist priests and Tang-ki spirit mediums are equivalent to priests and spirit mediums as technical terms. Max Weber understood and compared various types of priests and spirit mediums as practitioners in this world. J.M. Atkinson also compared the two, characterizing priests as liturgy-centered religious professionals while describing spirit mediums as more performance-centered. Despite its binary structure, Kokan Sasaki looked upon it as having three elements: the divine king, priests, and spirit mediums. Masakazu Tanaka's work in Sri Lanka-observing a secular caretaker within the priest and spirit-medium framework-focused on the struggle for power within the temple, also pointing out the subordinate nature of spirit mediums to priests in rituals. In the studies about the religious professionals in Singapore, Vivienne Wee, Sasaki and I described the action of the Tang-ki spirit-mediums as being interdependent with the worshippers, depending on the circumstances. Stephan Feuchtwang analyzed rituals in China, and pointed out that priest rituals were not merely communicative but also consequential, as they were performative. In religious festivals, a deity represents the liturgical community chosen for its efficacious protection. The implicit judgment of the conduct of its selected leader and god is played out. If, over a period of many years, the god is no longer considered to be efficaciously responsive, it will be abandoned or augmented by the choice of another god. Consequently, worshippers seek an accurate response from the gods whenever they make a vow. Alan Elliott and Leon Comber, meanwhile, paid attention to both religious professionals and supporters in the temple. Elliott demonstrated how a seance in the temple consisted of three elements: namely, the Tang-ki spirit mediums, the supporters, and the lay worshippers. However, he failed to examine the reciprocal relationship among the three. Comber regarded the Tang-ki spirit mediums as the most important religious professionals, as they give direct advice to worshippers. More recently, Khun Eng Kuah-Pearce looked at the streamlining of supporter's groups in temple. For example, the chairman changed the administrative method in the 1990s and later, referring the matter to a temple committee. The wishes of the committee members and worshippers relating to the administration of the temple are thus no longer disregarded. The paper also focuses on the triadic relation among the chairman, Daoist priests and Tang-ki spirit mediums, investigating whether or not the relationship between the priests and spirit-mediums is complementary. To that end, Chapter 2 introduces a general view of temple worship to help enhance the readers' understanding of Chinese religion. It includes explanations of various religious professionals, as well as the membership makeup of the temple, the types of supernatural beings, and the membership makeup of the temple board. The topic of the case study, temple A in Singapore, is taken up. The chapter also includes a history of the temple, the Daoist priests, Tang-ki spiri-mediums, the temple's administrative system, and former villagers. Chapter 3 goes on to investigate annual rituals held at the temple. The first is the New Year ritual, which is supervised only by the spirit mediums, and is concerned with relatively inferior supernatural beings. The second is the Hungry Ghost Festival, in which the priests manage the worship ritual for supernatural beings from the underworld cooperatively with the spirit mediums, but without the
(View PDF for the rest of the abstract.)
View full abstract