This study was intended to find out some personality types of institutional children, by using the Rorschach technique. We took up the modes of control as criteria to classify the personality patterns. The modes of control, which B. Klopfer divided into three, namely “Outer”,“Inner”, and “Constrictive control”, are considered to be important criteria of the effectiveness of general adjustment. But we divided “Outer control” into two, as our former study had demonstrated the large number of Shading and Achromatic responses to be a marked characteristic of institutional children. Thus “Socialized control” and “Control through Withdrawal” were established as criteria. Each mode of control was thought to be represented by the proportions below.
(a) Socialized control FC>CF+C, Sum C>1
(b) Inner control M≥FM+m, M≥2
(c) Control through Withdrawal Fc+cF+C'≥FC+CF+C
(d) Constrictive control A%≥65, F%≥65
One hundred and twelve children in an institution were divided into four groups, according to which mode of control was dominant in them.
I SI-type (N=21) maintains both Socialized and Inner control.
II O-type (N=40) maintains neither mode of control.
III W-type (N=26) maintains the control through Withdrawal. IV C-type (N=25) maintains the Constrictive control.
1) The validity of the group-division was tested by matching the groups with the nurses' rating as “superior”,“ordinary”, and “problem child” in regards to the children's general adjustment in the institution. The over-all chi-square test was significant at one per cent level. Regarding the SI-type, 8 members out of 21 were rated as “superior children”, and only 2 as “problem children”. On the contrary, none of the C-type were rated as “superior”, and 7 out of 25 as “problem children”. 0-and W-type had about same number of “superior” and “problem” children respectively.(Table 5)
2) These types were analysed with regard to age levels. As children grow older, O-type decreases and other types increase in number. The 2×3 chisquare test was significant at one per cent level.
(Table 6)
3) The relations between these types and other aspects of the Rorschach data were analysed. The + entry in Table 7 shows that sixty per cent or more children in the type exceeded the median of total group on that Rorschach symbol. Similarly, theentry shows that less than forty per cent of the type exceeded the median on that symbol. The type which has more + or - entries will be thought to be more coherent in members' personalities, at the same time various aspects of each type will be observed in the qualities of signed entries involved in the type.
4) The characteristics of each type will be assumed as below.
I SI-type Maintains social norms, well adjusted in the interpersonal relationship; wideinner life and high intellectual capacities. But a large number of indefinite Shading responses suggests the existence of vague anxiety caused from frustrating affectional needs.
II O-type Considered as significant from the point of development, but not significant on other aspects. Large number of indefinite form responses suggest the superficial and immediate expression of emotion. Generally lacks control.
III W-type Shows rather depressive tendencies; tries to control himself by social isolation; has developed stereotyped manner of action to prevent himself from emotional explosion.
IV C-type Lacks productivity; narrow range of inner life; can not contact emotionally with others; lacks spontaneity.
View full abstract