The purpose of the present research was to investigate the relationship among teachers' instructions to pupils, the children's individual characteristics, and the children's frequency of speaking in small-group learning. A questionnaire for children, completed by 463 elementary school children, covered cognitive empathy, self-evaluation of academic performance in science, frequency of speaking in class, and cognition of the outcomes. A questionnaire for teachers, completed by 15 science teachers, included questions about frequency of instructions. On the basis of scores on frequency of instructions (high-middle-low), empathy (high-low), and self-evaluation (high-low), the children were divided into 12 groups, and analyses of variance were conducted on the questionnaire results in order to determine whether there were any differences among these groups. The results were as follows: (1) children who reported that they spoke out frequently had both high empathy and high academic ability,(2) when teachers instructed the children, even children who indicated low self-evaluation and high empathy spoke out to some degree, and (3) children who indicated high self-evaluation and low empathy may be negatively affected by teachers' instructions.
View full abstract