The superoxide anion scavenging capacity of 11 antioxidants (AH) was observed, and the results were compared with the antioxidant capacity as measured by DPPH and galvinoxyl methods. The superoxide anion was generated by the xanthine/xanthine oxidase system. 4-[3-(4-iodophenyl)-2-(4- nitrophenyl)-2H-5-tetrazolio]-1,3-benzene disulfonate sodium salt (WST-1) was used as a probe of the superoxide anion. The color development rates of WST-1 were measured under various [AH]/[WST-1] ratios, and the data obtained were analyzed according to the following formula. R=ΔA
0/ΔA=1+(k
A/k
W)*([AH]/[WST-1]), where ΔA
0 and ΔA are the color development rates of WST-1 in the absence and presence of antioxidants, respectively, and k
A and k
W are the rate constants of the reaction of superoxide anion with the antioxidants and WST-1. The slope k
A/k
W calculated from the linear regression of the plot of [AH]/[WST-1] vs. V
0/V, indicated the relative superoxide anion scavenging capacity of each antioxidant. The superoxide anion scavenging capacity decreased in the order of caffeic acid, n-propyl gallate, 7,8-dihydroxyflavone, gallic acid, catechin, pyrogallol, quercetin, L-ascorbic acid, BHA, 4-hydroxycoumarin and ferulic acid. Correlation coefficients between the superoxide anion scavenging capacity and the antioxidant capacity as measured by the galvinoxyl or DPPH method were as low as 0.448 (galvinoxyl method) and 0.368 (DPPH method), and it was shown that the antioxidant capacity measured by DPPH method or galvinoxyl method does not necessarily reflect the scavenging capacity of superoxide anion.
View full abstract