The Japan Neck Dissection Study Group (JNDSG) receives support in the form of a Health and Labour Sciences Research Grant for Clinical Cancer Research from the Ministry of Health, Labour and Welfare, Japan, to conduct the “Study on Standardization of Surgery for Cervical Lymph Node Metastases of Head and Neck Cancer (H17-Gannrinshou-001).”
There are significant differences in the extent of resection of the cervical lymph nodes and non-lymphatic structures among neck dissections conducted in the large cancer centers in Japan.To eliminate these differences, the JNDSG has planned a multi-institutional prospective study, in which a surgeon of an institution visits another institution and observes neck dissection conducted by a surgeon of the visited institution, to complete our observation form composed of 79 detailed questions about the ongoing neck dissection.The observation forms will be collected and analyzed to extract questions when answers are significantly different among institutions and to initiate standardizing processes for surgical details concerning these questions.The standardizing processes include establishment of scientific evidence and, if scientific evidence is difficult to obtain, round-table discussions are held.The estimated number of enrolled patients is 235 in total.
Twenty-two institutions have participated in the study.During Feb. 18, 2004 and June 10, 2005, 106 patients were registered.According to the analysis of 74 patients, or 100 neck dissections, in the first step of the study, a significant difference among the institutions was observed for 16 surgical details, such as the upper resection line of the superior deep cervical nodes, the inferior resection line of the inferior deep cervical nodes, resection of the lymph nodes located postero-superiorly to the spinal accessory nerve, and resection of the sternocleidomastoid muscle.We will repeat the analysis of the observation forms to make the extracting process more precise and to make the standardizing processes more efficient.
View full abstract