Extra thyroidal extension (ETE) of thyroid papillary carcinoma (PAC) is known as a risk factor of poor prognosis. The ATA Guideline recommends total thyroidectomy (TT) with radioiodine ablation for patients of PACs with ETE and we have been following this strategy for cases of PACs with ETE. In this paper, we retrospectively examined the patients of PACs with ETE in terms of the following two issues: 1) Does
131I total body scan (
131I-TBS) after TT enable us to detect subclinical distant metastases of PACs? and 2) Can
131I ablation eliminate microscopic remnants of PACs after TT?
The subjects consisted of 68 patients who had PACs with ETE and underwent
131I-TBS and/or
131I ablation after TT in our hospital in the past 20 years. TNM classifications of the patients were pT3: pT4=12: 56, pN0: pN1a: pN1b=13: 15: 40, M0: M1=62: 6. Twenty-two cases underwent only
131I-TBS and 46 cases underwent
131I-ablation. Fourteen cases diagnosed as M0 preoperatively had distant focus detected using
131I-TBS (1). Including M1 cases, 20 out of 68 cases (29%) turned out to have clinical or subclinical distant lesions in our study.
131I ablation eliminated thyroid bed in 18 out of 22 cases, and distant foci in 5 out of 13 cases (2). However, the distant lesions which had been apparent before operation (M1 cases) did not reach CR by
131I ablation. In 22 out of those 23 cases successfully treated with the ablation, serum-thyroglobulin level was almost undetected after therapy. The overall 10-year survival rate was 82% and the cause-specific survival rate was 91%.
View full abstract