Artificial porcelain denture teeth have many outstanding properties. In addition to being hygienic, they are the most resistant to abrasion of all currently used dental materials, maintain long-lasting cusps, and are resistant to denture plaque deposition and discoloration. However, they are vulnerable to impact and easily fracture, tend to make occlusal sounds, and do not bind to denture resins. For these reasons they are rarely used. We focused this study on their susceptibility to fracture, which is one reason preventing their more widespread use, and investigated the fractures that occurred. The experimental materials were the upper and lower first molars of six commercially available brands of porcelain teeth.
Experiments were carried out using an abrasion-testing device developed in our laboratory, adapted to deliver a specific impact force. An upper artificial tooth was placed on the top of the abrasion-testing device and a lower artificial tooth was placed on the bottom in normal physiologic relation. The device was set to deliver occlusal contact at a load of 162.2 N. The upper artificial tooth made repeated occlusal contact with the lower artificial tooth 60 times/minute in a tapping movement, which was repeated until one of the teeth fractured or for a maximum of 2,000 times, and the number of impacts until fracture was counted. This test was carried out on ten teeth for each of the six brands of porcelain teeth.
Of the six brands, five teeth from one brand, three from another, and one from a third did not fracture, even after 2,000 impacts. For all brands, more fractures occurred among upper teeth than among lowers. A total of 56 upper and lower artificial teeth fractured, with these fractures occurring at the marginal ridge in 25 cases, associated with the marginal ridge in 19, and not associated with it in 12. Aside from the teeth that did not fracture even after 2,000 impacts, analysis of the number of impacts until fracture showed that the teeth that lasted longest before breaking underwent an average 1,029 impacts. The next longest withstood an average of 794 impacts. The artificial tooth that fractured after the smallest number of impacts withstood only 16 taps. The next smallest number was 121 impacts.
Our results indicate that the susceptibility to fracture varies among the different brands of artificial teeth, and that in many cases, fracture is associated with occlusal contact with the marginal ridge.
View full abstract