Multivariate analyses were performed, first, to clarify the relationship between postoperative anterior laxity and postoperative quadriceps muscle strength; second, to elucidate the effects of these two parameters on results, evaluated with the Lysholm score; and, third, to ascertain preoperative or intraoperative factors that affect postoperative anterior laxity or postoperative quadriceps muscle strength. Subjects were 123 patients who underwent ACL reconstruction using the hamstring tendons in their unilateral knee since 1989. Age ranged from 13 to 53 years, and the postoperative follow-up period ranged from 2 to 5 years. Patients underwent identical surgery and postoperative management. There was no correlation between postoperative anterior laxity and postoperative quadriceps muscle strength (r=0.03) . These results show that these two parameters are independent of each other. Postoperative anterior laxity significantly affected results, which were evaluated with the Lysholm score (p=0.03), although postoperative quadriceps muscle strength had no significant effect on the results (p=0.23) . Among possible factors that might affect postoperative anterior laxity, the multivariate analysis demonstrated that initial graft tension applied during surgery and age at the time of operation significantly affected postoperative anterior laxity. Namely, postoperative anterior laxity was low when the initial graft tension was high, and in cases of advanced age. On the other hand, only preoperative sports level significantly affected postoperative quadriceps muscle strength. That is, when the preoperative sports level was high, postoperative muscle strength was great.
View full abstract