In contrast to the scalar electrocardiogram, which merely shows changes of the potential difference of the lead, the aim of the spatial vectorcardiogram is to show the cardiac electromotive force directly. Whether this can be recorded faithfully or not, overcoming difficult problems between the cardiac electric generator and the human body conductor, depends on the development of the basic theories of the electrocardiogram, on the basis of which the lead systems of the vectorcardiogram have been devised. A discussion is described on the discrepancies resulting from the old simple theories and on the extent to which they are resolved by recent theories originated by Burger and Van Milaan and developed by, Frank, Schmitt, McFee and Johnston, and others.
Whether we should choose the old simple but practical theory or the new complicated theory of the electrocardiogram depends upon the degree of accuracy required for each purpose. It is not that the old concept was wrong and the new one is correct. In every-day reading of electrocardiograms the first approximation, such as Einthoven's model, and the old concept, is probably still more-or-less sufficient. But it has been shown that the old concept is probably not sufficient as the basic theory of vectorcardiography. One of the reasons is that vectorcardiograms from the same person obtained by different old systems often differ remarkably from each other, whereas those obtained by new systems resemble each other much more. This does not mean that the latter are perfect, because with closer comparison, we can find many minute points of difference even among them. It is hoped to devise a more accurate and practical lead system, if possible. To discover new practical values of the vectorcardiogram proper it is suggested that more attention be paid to the shape of the vector loop, (circular, ellipsoild, linear etc), which is caused by the minute phase difference of the two perpendicular leads introduced into the cathode-ray-oscilloscope.
The vectorcardiogram has, for a long time struggled to establish its own raison d'être in rivalry with the electrocardiogram, but now the fight seems about to end, since both will be united in a form for automatic diagnosis of electrical phenomena of the heart. The only choice is which is better to introduce into the computer. Or a quite new form may have to be devised for this purpose.
View full abstract