Following the previous studies17) on the distillation of the benzene-toluene system in a packed column, experiments were performed for the purpose of studying the effects of operating variables on the distillation of systems as well as the difference in the column performance due to the kinds of systems employed. The apparatus used was the same as in the previous studies, and the systems employed here were methanol-water and ethanol-water systems. The column was 15cm in inside diameter and was packed to a height of 54cm. It was operated as an enriching section and at total reflux. The HOG and KLa values obtained are shown in Figs. 1 and 2. From these figures and others, which are not shown here, it was concluded that both vapor and liquid phase resistances to mass transfer cannot be neglected.
H
P (H.E.T.P.) values were also calculated for all the runs, including the previous data
17) on the benzene-toluene system. The ratio of H
OG to H
P can be fairly well represented by the known Eq. (5), if the average slope of the equilibrium curve, m, as defined by Eq. (3) or (4) is substituted for m in Eq. (5). In general, so far as H
G and H
L are nearly equal, the variation of H
P values with the change of mG
M/L
M is smaller than that of H
OG or H
OL values. This is obvious from Figs. 4 and 5, in which H
P values are plotted against the liquid mass rate, L, with gas mass rate, G, as a parameter. For instance, comparison of Figs. 1 and 4 clearly shows the smaller variation of HP values. Thus, it can be said that H
P is a more practical criterion than H.T.U. for designing packed distillation columns.
H
P values vary with systems, but no general correlation involving physical properties of the systems was obtained.
Experiments were also made for the comparison of the performance of various packings. 25mm and 15mm Raschig rings, 25mm and 12mm Berl saddles, and 25mm and 15mm coke packings were tested. The comparisons between these packings are shown in Fig. 6. For a given type of packing, the HP values are roughly proportional to the 1/3 power of the size of the packing. For a given size, the coke packing shows the lowest HP values, and the difference between Raschig ring and Berl saddle is negligible. The coke packing gives the highest resistance to vapor flow, while Berl saddles show the lowest pressure drop. However, the pressure drop per theoretical plate for coke packings is nearly equal to that for Raschig rings. The Berl saddle has the merit of low pressure drop, while the coke packing has the advantage of very low cost. For the performance of coke packings, refer to the paper by Yoshida and Koyanagi
16).
View full abstract