A double blind comparative study on scarlet fever was performed with bacampicillin (BAPC), an ethoxycarbonyloxyethyl ester of ampicillin (ABPC), and Talampicillin (TAPC), a phtalidyl ester of ABPC.
1. A total of 133 patients were treated with BAPC and 134 with TAPC. BAPC capsules or TAPC capsules were made to contain 50 mg activity of ABPC.
2. Patients weighing less than 20 kg were administered at a daily dose of 400 mg activity (8capsules in four equally divided doses). Patients weighing 20 kg or more and less than 30 kg were administered at a daily dose of 600 mg activity (12 capsules in four equally divided doses).
All patients were administered for 7 days.
3. Thirty-one patients were excluded and one patient was dropped out. Analyses for assessment were made on 120 patients of the BAPC group and 115 patients of the TAPC group.
4. There were no significant differences in all background characteristics between the two groups.
5. A total of 136 strains of streptococci isolated from the pharynx were examined. The MIC to ABPC and PCG were all under 0.025μg/ml.
6. In 115/120 (95.8%) of the BAPC group and 110/115 (95.6%) of the TAPC group, the overall clinical efficacy was judged as excellent or good.
In 116/120 (96.7%) of the BAPC group and 112/115 (97.4%) of the TAPC group, the clinical usefulness was judged as very satisfactory or satisfactory.
There was no significant difference between the two groups.
7. In most cases of both groups, pharyngeal streptococci disappeared within 24 hours after initiation of medication.
8. In four cases of the BAPC group and one case of the TAPC group, streptococci reappeared in the pharynx after the drug administration.
9. Daily improvements of body temperature, exanthema, pharyngeal redness and pharyngeal streptococci were not significantly different between the two drugs.
10. Side effects, such as mild drug eruption, diarrhea and vomiting were observed in six cases of the BAPC group.
One case of loose stool was observed in the TAPC group. But there was not significant difference between the two groups.
11. Laboratory parameters were examined for each 122 cases of both groups before and after the medication.
An elevation of transaminase and an eosinophilia were observed in both groups, none of which was, however, not serious.
From this comparative study, we concluded that BAPC was as effective and as useful as TAPC for the therapy of scarlet fever.
View full abstract