The clinical usefulness of Enoxacin (ENX, AT-2266), a new oral antibacterial agent, was compared with that of pipemidic acid (PPA) in the treatment of acute infectious diarrhea (bacillary dysentery, Campylobacter enteritis and enteropathogenic and enterotoxigenic E. coli enteritis) by a double-blind method.
Daily dosage of ENX and PPA was 600mg and 2000mg, respectively.
The duration of the treatment was 5 days.
Of 242 cases treated, various statistical analyses were carried out in 146 case, and 96 cases were excluded.
Of 146 cases, 73 cases were treated with ENX or PPA respectively. There was no statistical significance between ENX group and PPA group in terms of the background characteristics and MIC distribution against each drug.
The results obtained were as follows.
1. The MICs of ENX against the isolates ranged between <0.1 and 1.56μg/ml, whilethose from PPA, between 0.78 and 12.5μg/ml. No resistant strains against ENX and PPA were observed in the causative organisms.
2. In bacillary dysentery, the bacteriological effect of ENX (97.1%) was superiorto that of PPA (83.6%).
3. In bacillary dysentery, the frequency of redischarge of the causative organisms was 2.9% in ENX group and 14.9% in PPA group. A statistically significant difference was observed between ENX group and PPA group.
4. There was no significant difference between ENX group and PPA group in improvement of clinical symptoms by any causative organisms.
5. Side effects were observed in one case of ENX group (0.9%) and 5 cases of PPA group (4.2%). There was no statistically significant difference between both groups. Abnormalities in laboratory tests were slight elevation of s-GPT in ENX group andincrease in eosinophil fraction (percentage) in PPA group.
6. On clinical usefulness judged by the physicians, the ratio of usefulness were 84.6% in ENX group and 66.7% in PPA group in bacillary dysentery. Usefulness of ENX was superior to that of PPA group.
7. The effects on Campylobacter enteritis, enteropathogenic and enterotoxigenic E. coli enteritis could not be assessed because of a small number of cases.
As mentioned above, ENX is considered to be useful medication in the treatment of patients with bacillary dysentery and carriers.
View full abstract