In the first study, the Tuberculosis Research Committee, Rytiken (Japan), reported theresults of therapeutic effect of rifampicin (RFP) on re-treatment cases of pulmonary tuberculosis (Kekkaku, Vol.45. p.227), in which the combination of RFP with ethambutol (EB) showed an excellent therapeutic effect, and no difference in the effect was observed betweenthe regimen with daily administration of both drugs and that of rifampicin twice weeklycombined with ethambutol daily.
The second report presents the results of the therapeutic effect of combination regimen ofRFP with EB and pyrazinamide (PZA) on re-treatment cases of pulmonary tuberculosis.
Patients whose cultures had failed to convert to negative in spite of long-term treatment with primary and secondary anti-tuberculous drugs, other than RFP, EB and PZA, and whose sputahad been positive at least for three consecutive months were assigned to the following fiveregimens randomly.The five regimens are shown in Table 1.
The dose of drugs was determined according to body weight and mode of administration, daily or intermittent (Table 2). The drugs were given in a single daily dose before breakfast.
Among 196 cases submitted to the study, 46 were excluded from the analysis because ofnegative culture before study or of drop-out within six months, etc. The number of casesexcluded and reason for exclusion are shown in Table 3, and the patients discontinued medication because of the side-effects of the drugs were included in the study. The backgroundfactors of the patients sex, body weight, bacteriological findings, NTA classification, X-rayfindings etc are shown in Table 4. The duration of the study was twelve months.
The results are summarized as follows: Bacteriological findings and interruption of the assigned regimen because of side-effectsduring six-month treatment were analysed in 30, 29, 31, 31 and 29 cases in each regimen asshown in Table 5 and Figure 1. The rate of negative culture and the cumulative rate of dropout cases because of side-effects within six months did not differ markedly among the threecombined regimens of RFP, EB and PZA twice weekly or daily; the rates of negative culturewere 70 to 74% and the rates of drop-out cases due to side-effects were 14 to 20%. Theregimen of RFP daily with EB twice weekly (Regimen V) achieved, however, 79% ofnegative conversion rate at 6 th month and 3.4% of drop-out rate due to side-effects withinsix months. In the Regimen IV, drop-out cases due to side-effects were none, but the rateof negative culture was 61% at 6 th month of the therapy.
The rate of favourable cases (consecutively negative cultures at 4th, 5th and 6 th months) after six-month treatment was 65 to 70% in the regimens I, II and III, and 48% in theregimen IV, 76% in the regimen V (Figure 2). The rate of unfavourable cases after sixmonth treatment (including drop-out cases due to side-effects) was highest in the regimen IVand lowest in the regimen V. Among unfavourable cases, nearly half of the cases was thedrop-out cases because of side-effects in the regimens I, II and III in which PZA werecombined with.
The rate of bacteriological relapse among favourable cases at 6 th month was low in thefollowing six months (Table 6).
View full abstract