Cases of pulmonary tuberculosis who were previously untreated and most of them with far advanced lesions were treated by the alternative chemotherapeutic regimen consisting of the following two kinds of triple combinations SM·INH·PAS for 3 months, KM·TH·CS for 3 months
The total number of cases accepted to the trial was 163, but 55 cases were excluded due to various reasons shown in Table 1.
Background factors of the remaining 108 cases and those of far advanced cases were presented in Table 2 and Fig. 1, respectively. Up to the end of 6 th month, 12% of the cases dropped out and up to 12th month 28.7%, and the causes of dropout were shown in Tables 3 and 5.
The negative conversion of sputum at 12th month was 98.6% by smear and 97.8% by culture, and for far advanced cases, the rates were 98.4% and 97.4%, respectively.
The drug sensitivity tests were performed for culture positive cases, and 16 cases showed resistance to at least one of the above six drugs during the former half year, and another 1 case became resistant during the latter half year.
At 12th month, significant improvement in chest X-ray findings was seen in 53.8%, and that of cavity was 38.0%. (Tables 9 and 10)
Various side-effects were seen in 80 cases or 56.3%, and in 19 cases, the regimen had to be changed because of severe adverse reactions.
Matched pairs were made from our previous trial groups treated originally with SM·INH·PAS, and as shown in Table 12 and Fig. 5, the pairs were comparable. No significant difference was found between the pairs as to the sputum conversion rate and the cavity closure rate.
It is concluded that the alternative regimen consisting of the major drugs and three of the minor drugs does not give more favourable clinical results as compared with the standard triple drug regimen.
View full abstract