This study was made to review the present status of surgical treatment for the tuberculous empyema in Japan. The material consisted of 552 cases who had been operated upon at 36 institutions belonging to Tuberculosis Research Committee (RYOKEN) during 4 years' period from 1968 to 1971 and followed up for the period of at least 6 months postoperatively.
In this study the died case not related to the thoracic operation and tuberculous worsening were excluded. The tuberculous empyema case was defined as the case who had had a purulent or pus-like fluid in the pleural space after the onset of pulmonary tuber culosis, or during and after treatment of pulmonary tuberculosis. The primary empyema case was difined as the case not related to the thoracic operation and the secondary one as the case related to the thoracic operation. The total empyema case was defined as the case with empyema space expanding around from apex to diaphragm and the partial empyema case as the case with smaller empyema space than the above mentioned on the radiogram.
The empyema cases were classified into 3 types by the causes, the presence of fistula and the size of empyema space; the primary and secondary, the fistulous and nonfistulous, and the total and partial empyema.
The ratio of primary cases to secondary cases was 60%: 40%, that of fistulous cases to nonfistulous cases was 70%: 30% and that of total cases to partial cases was 45%: 55%.
The causes of empyema were quite different in the primary and secondary empyema; the pleurisy comprised 63.5%, the artificial pneumothorax 29.5% and the spontaneous pneumothorax 7.1% in the former and the failure of pulmonary resection comprised 76.6%, the failure of extrapleural plombage 14.6%, the failure of cavernostomy 4.4%, the failure of thoracoplasty 3.1 % and the other operations 1.3% in the latter. The failure of pulmonary resection was more predominant as the cause of empyema in the secondary fistulous cases than in the secondary nonfistulous cases.
Regarding the preoperative background factors, cases with %VC less than 40 were found in 17.0% and cases with %VC more than 71 only in 21, 6% in all cases, whereas 20.4% and 15.9% in the fistulous cases, and 8.5% and 35.3% in the nonfistulous cases, respectively. Cases with FEV1.0/PVC less than 30 occupied 24.9% and cases with FEV
1.0/PVC more than 61 occupied 12.9% in all cases. The former was 28.8% in the fistulous cases and the latter was 25.3% in the nonfistulous cases. According to these findings the preoperative respiratory function was lower in the empyema case as compared with that of the usual tuberculosis cases.
The bacteriologic study of a pus obtained from the empyema space just before and/or during the operation revealed the infection rate of 43.0% in which tubercle bacilli. were found in 16.4%, cocci in 16.0%, both tubercle bacilli and cocci in 6.1%, fungus in 1.9% and others in 2.6%. This finding differed markedly according to the type of empyema; a high percentage of infection rate by cocci were seen in the fistulous cases than in the nonfistulous cases. The same tendency was proved between the primary cases and the secondary cases.
View full abstract