Open-negative' cavities in the lung usually are the results of chemotherapy. The cavities once excreted tubercle bacilli and thereafter ceased to excrete the bacilli after chemotherapy with antituberculous agents are usually called open-negative cavities. In contrast to these, there are cavities of another type which do not show acid-fast organism from the beginning of observation. The author experienced 4 cases of this type (open-negative cavity) to due infection with atypical mycobacteria.
Three patients, a 16 year-old male, a 39 year-old female and a 28 year-old male, did not show acid-fast organism in their sputum for 5 months, 11 months and 23 months, respectively, by monthly (or more) sputum examinations. The patients received lung resection. From the cavities resected (right lower lobe, left upper lobe and left upper lobe, respectively),
Mycobacterium intracellulare (the former two cases) and
Mycobacterium chelonei subsp. chelonei (the third case) were isolated.
Another patient, a 67 year-old female, did not show acid-fast organism by monthly examinations for 4 years, and thereafter the patient began to discharge M. intracellulare in the sputum. After the first appearance of the organism, the organism was isolated 9 times by monthly examinations in 2 years. The amount of the organism on isolation medium varied from 3 to a few hundred colonies. A thin-walled cavity with slight pericavitary lesions was observed in left upper lobe of the patient from the beginning of observation. The X-ray picture did not show any significant change during 6 years of the observation period.
All four patients showed a solitary, thin-walled cavity without or, if any, with only slight pericavitary lesions. No significant drainage bronchus was observed on the X-ray picture, except for the fourth patient. Chemotherapy with antituberculous agents did not modify the X-ray picture.
The reason why the organisms were not found in the sputum is considered as follows; thin walled cavities contain a little amount of acid-fast organisms, and only a few amount of the organisms are excreted into sputum, and they are escaped from routine sputum examinations.
In conclusion, thin-walled cavities due to infection with atypical mycobacteria may appear as open-negative cavities.
View full abstract