Indication of surgical treatment for pulmonary tuberculosis in recent years has changed remarkably due to the development of initial intensive chemotherapy containing RFP, and it seems that more difficult cases to cure has increased because of the increase of preoperative sputum positive cases which are resistant case to potent drugs such as SM, INH and RFP. This study was carried out to clarify present status of surgical treatment for pulmonary tuberculosis and its results by preoperative culture findings of tubercle bacilli.
Study subjects were 968 cases of pulmonary tuberculosis in which culture findings of tubercle bacilli in sputum within two months prior to surgical treatment was available and surgical treatment was carried out in 53 institutions belonging to Tuberculosis Research Committee during the period of 6 years from 1976 to 1981.
Number of cases operated in 1976 was 251, and since then, it has decreased year by year and fell down to 113 in 1981.
Culture positive cavitary cases have increased year by year, while culture negative cavitary cases have decreased. Culture negative noncavitary cases have increased to some extent and about one thirds of them were operated because of suspicion of lung cancer.
Resistant cases to more than three drugs including RFP have also increased and reached 57% in 1981.
Cases with FEV1/VCpr “Index” less than 40 have decreased.
Observing the mode of operation, lobectomy occupied more than half of all operated cases in both culture positive and culture negative cases, followed by thoracoplasty and pneumonectomy in culture positive cases, and other resections excluding pneumonectomy and lobectomy in culture negative cases.
Observing the mode of operation employed showed that thoracoplasty and pneumonectomy decreased in 1980 but again increased in 1981, in culture positive cases, and pneumonectomy increased again in 1981 in culture negative cases. These changes suggest the increase of cases more difficult to treat.
The results of surgical treatment were as follows: In culture positive cases, success was 84.6%, negative bacilli 87.9%, positive bacilli 9.3%, death 2.8% and postoperative complica tions 11.1%. In culture negative cases, success was 96.8%, negative bacilli 98.6%, positive bacilli 1.1%, death 0.3% and postoperative complications 1.4%. These results were better than those obtained during the period of 6 years from 1963 to 1968.
Observing annual trend of the results, it was best in 1979 in culture positive cases, and the results such as the rates of success and negative bacilli have dropped and those of positive bacilli and complications have elevated gradually in 1980 and 1981. In culture negative cases, the best result was obtained in 1980 and it dropped in 1981.
View full abstract