Numerous studies on the natural history of HIV-infection have revealed that the number of CD4
+T lymphocytes in peripheral blood was the most important determining factor for the occurrence of various opportunistic infections and the most reliable prognosis indicator for the progression of HIV-infection to AIDS. It is also generally accepted that CD4
+T lymphocytes are the key cells in protective immunity in tuberculosis. Basing on these knowledges, we tried to analyze the significance of the number of CD4
+T lymphocyte in the development of clinical tuberculosis from latent infection with tubercle bacilli.
Of 84 tuberculosis patients, younger than 70 years old, who had been analyzed lymphocyte subsets by flow cytometry (FACS), six patients (one female, five males) had remarkably reduced number of CD4
+T lymphocytes (≤250 cells/mm
3) by their first FACS analysis after diagnosis. Any obvious risk behavior and/or habit was noticed in none of the six patients, three of whom were in the twenties.
FACS analyses of these six cases revealed that:
1) The proportion of total lymphocytes to total leukocytes was remarkably lower than that of tuberculosis patients as a whole as well as than that of healthy control group.
2) The numbers of total lymphocytes, T lymphocytes and CD4+Tlymphocytes were all far below the normal range. (mean)2-SD of the control group).
3) The proportion of CD8
+T lymphocytes to total lymphocytes was higher in five of these six cases, but the number of CD8+T lymphocytes was lower in all six than the respeCtive mean value of the control group.
4) CD4
+/CD8
+ratio was lower than 1 except in two cases.
In two cases, FACS analysis was carried out rather long after the diagnosis and the judgement was difficult, but the remaining four patients developed their tuberculosis with uncommon and/or very severe clinical features, such as miliary tuberculosis, bI3 type, acute relapse of tuberculosis complicated with aspergillosis and “adult type” pulmonary tuberculosis accompanied with exudative pleurisy, and we judged that the defective cellular immunity, as revealed by remarkably reduced number of CIA+ T lymphocytes, was the main determining factor for the development of their tuberculosis.
In addition, all six cases showed more or less unfavorable clinical course and/or bad prognosis (one: death of tuberculosis, one: death of pulmonary aspergillosis) even under intensified anti-tuberculosis therapy. The reduced number of CIA+T lymphocytes might be considerd as the important determining factor, or, at the least, can be useful as the prognosis indicator for such unfavorable clinical course and prognosis.
Possible applications of monitoring of CD4
+T lymphocytes in treatment and control of the patients with tuberculosis were discussed.
View full abstract