Comparative effect of ten organophosphorus insecticides, i. e. diazinon, malathion, DDVP, ronnel, Dibrom, Baytex, Acethion, Butonate and Sumithion to a colony of German cockroach, Blattella germanica L., was studied in laboratory conditions. Some chlorinated hydrocarbon insecticides were also tested for comparison. After topical application test, DDVP was most effective; Sumithion was the next; and the descending order in the effectiveness was as follows : Dibrom, dieldrin, lindane, Baytex, diazinon, malathion, chlordane, Diepterex, ronnel, Butonate, DDT, Acethion. In rapidity of knockdown assessed by film contact test, DDVP was most excellent; Dibrom was the next; and the descending order in rapidity was as follows : lindane, diazinon, malathion, Sumithion, Baytex, Dipterex, ronnel, dieldrin, chlordane, DDT. The residual effect estimated from the mortality 6 days after the contact for limitted time to the residues kept in room conditions was excellent in Sumithion and Baytex, and inferior in Dibrom, ronnel and Dipterex. Summarizing the data obtained here and in the previous paper by Suzusuki, Shirai and Matsunaga (1961), for the use of residual application to cockroach, dieldrin was most excellent; Sumithion and Baytex were the next; lindane, chlordane and diazinon were the third; and the other chemicals were far inferior to the above chemicals.
View full abstract