This research focused on examining three elementary school grade levels, specifically children in the
first, second, and third grades. It sought to examine how university students studying to become
elementary school teachers are taught competency formation methods by coming to understand the
spatial awareness development tendencies of early elementary school students through the use of
introductory-level instruction using maps, which is an area that had not yet been examined.
For the first and second graders being investigated, it became clear that a large percentage of the
maps that they sketched consisted of a single specific route (route maps). Maps sketched by third
graders were a mix of route maps and maps showing a network of multiple roads (survey maps), and as
children move up through the middle grades of elementary school, survey maps become more and
more common.
There were many examples of things included in maps sketched by children that assist in spatial
awareness like landform features such as hilly roads, things related to friendship such as parks or
houses of friends, things related to consumption such as shops, and things related to traffic/movement
such as traffic signals/pedestrian crossings. The next most common things included were related to
land use such as temples/shrines and parking lots. From this, we understand that children choose to
include in maps aspects related to landform features, friendship, consumption, and movement/traffic.
In an examination of university students studying to become teachers, it became clear that they tend
to overestimate the ability to draw maps of children in the lower grades, and that university students
tend to include things from their own experience when they create large maps to be placed on the floor.
It is necessary to coach university students to understand the necessity of field work and trying to
understand the actual situation of children since university students tend to rely on their own daily life
experiences when creating teaching materials.
As part of teacher training, university students should be coached to become competent at ensuring
children have a smooth transition from large maps placed on the floor (used in life environmental
studies) to actual maps in the third grade and beyond, as well as connecting landscapes and maps by
creating maps that include directly-observed features of the local landscape. Based upon these
observations, it is effective for the competency formation of university students to participate in guided
field work, as well as to understand the actual situation of children from the perspective of children’s
spatial awareness and tendencies when creating maps.
View full abstract