It is said that tenancy disputes in which rent reductions were demanded in the 1920s weakened Japanese landlordism. The aim of this paper is to examine this statement by clarifying why and how these disputes occurred and ended, and how they affected Japanese landlordism. The study is based on the case of the Bisai textile industrial area in Aichi Prefecture, one of the most industrialized prefectures in the prewar period.
From 1917, tenant farmers in the Bisai area started a rent reducing movement. They succeeded in obtaining temporary or permanent reductions in rent. In the 1920s, levels of rent decreased by about 30 to 40 percent. However, after the latter half of the 1920s tenants could no longer effect such reductions in rent.
During and after World War I, the textile industry grew rapidly; as a result, tenant farming became much less profitable compared with the labor in industry. Tenant farmers were absorbed into the non-agricultural labor market, reducing the competition in land market. Under such circumstances, tenants required a reduction in land rent, which permitted them to earn incomes equivalent with wages in factories. However, in the latter half of the 1920s, the labor market shrank and the revived competition for rented land, tenants were no longer in a position to make demands in the disputes.
Through disputes, the economic position of landlords in this area declined. Rent ratios were reduced significantly, and the profit for landlords became smaller. The number of big landlords decreased notably. However, it should be pointed out that the case of Bisai was not typical. From the nationwide standpoint, there were not many areas where rent reducing disputes successfully weakened landlordism.
View full abstract