Light-colored soy sauce (
Usukuchi shoyu) is usually used for seasoning boiled dishes (
Nimono). Although
Usukuchi shoyu contains more NaCl by about 2% than
Koikuchi shoyu, many
Nimono cooke
d with
Usukuchi shoyu contain less NaCl than those cooked with
Koikuchi shoyu. This cooking phenomenon of
Usukuchi shoyu is experientially well known, and called as “
Usukuchi shoyu paradox”. In this paper, we studied the mechanisms of
Usukuchi shoyu paradox by two organoleptic evaluation methods. Firstly, we determined the discrimination threshold of saltiness in two kinds of
shoyus, and the concentration of NaCl in each
shoyu was significantly discriminated at 0.92% and at 0.95% in
Usukuchi shoyu (
p<0.05), and at 0.92% and at 0.97% in
Koikuchi shoyu (
p<0.001), respectively. Furthermore, dried bonito soup stock (
Katsuo-dashi) was significantly discriminated at 1.00% and at 1.25% in
Usukuchi shoyu (
p<0.01), and at 1.00% and at 1.50% in
Koikuchi shoyu (
p<0.05), respectively. Also, the discrimination threshold of the taste of seaweed soup stock (
Konbu-dashi) was less concentrated in
Usukuchi shoyu than in
Koikuchi shoyu. Secondly, the enhancing effect of saltiness was determined with probit method when
Katsuo-dashi,
Usukuchi shoyu and
Koikuchi shoyu were combined. Sample 1 was prepared as a combination of 4% of
Usukuchi shoyu and 3% of
Katsuo-dashi, and the saltiness of sample 1 was equivalent to 0.90% NaCl solution when the NaCl concentration of sample 1 was 0.872%. Sample 2 was prepared as a combination of 4% of
Koikuchi shoyu and 3% of
Katsuo-dashi, and the enhancing effect of saltiness was not confirmed. Although 4% of
Usukuchi shoyu, 4% of
Koikuchi shoyu, and 3% of
Katsuo-dashi did not show the enhancing effect of saltiness individually, the 95% confidential limits reinforced that only the combination of
Usukuchi shoyu and
Katsuo-dashi enhanced saltiness. In conclusion, the mechanism of
Usukuchi shoyu paradox was suggested as follows :
Usukuchi shoyu had a lower threshold for saltiness, which makes it easier to adjust appropriate saltiness required for
Nimono and a combination of
Usukuchi shoyu and
Katsuo-dashi enhanced saltiness. Therefore,
Nimono cooked with
Usukuchi shoyu would be palatable with less salt.
View full abstract