According to the treatment policy of our facility for otitis media with effusion (OME) in children, long-term ventilation tube placement (VTP) has been performed for intractable cases with prolonged middle ear effusion accompanying with suppressed growth of tympano-mastoid air cells. And for cases with adenoid hypertrophy, adenoidectomy was also performed under general anesthesia together with VTP. Furthermore, based on the relationship between duration of the ventilation tube placement and recurrence rate, the ventilation tube was placed for at least 18 months, in general.
In the present study, we examined factors, including the usefulness of adenoidectomy that influences the postoperative course after removing ventilation tubes for cases with OME in young children up to six years old. 161 ears in 161 young children ranging from 3 to 6 year old at the time of VTP were subjected to the study. These patients were hospitalized in our department from August 1980 to May 2008, and observed for one year after removing the tube. In the patients underwent bilateral tube insertion, only one ear exhibiting a less satisfactory prognosis. Subjects underwent VTP alone were categorized into the tube placement group and the subjects underwent adenoidectomy together with VTP into the adenoidectomy group.
In each group of children with good or poor prognosis, no significant effects of placement duration (21.2 months vs 20.0 months) and age (5.1 year old vs 4.8 year old at the time of VTP) on prognosis were seen. The degree of development of mastoid cells at the first visit was significantly greater in the good prognosis group than in the poor prognosis group (p<0.05, 22.5 cm
2 vs 9.5cm
2). Regarding the placement duration and prognosis after removing the tube, significantly higher incidence (p<0.01) of cases with good prognosis was noted in the group with placement duration of 18 months and more than in the group with the duration of less than 18 months, whereas no significant effects of the duration on prognosis were noted in adenoidectomy groups.
Taking into account the fact that VTP must be carried out under general anesthesia in younger children, it was considered that adenoidectomy was desirable at the time of VTP and thereby reduced a possibility of recurrence of OME as the result of early spontaneous loss of the tube, in general.
View full abstract