The purpose of this study was to evaluate the effects of Nd: YAG laser radiation on scaled and root-planed surfaces using scanning electron microscopy (SEM). The experimental materials were fifteen human teeth affected by severe periodontal disease, which had been extracted because of a hopeless prognosis. All of the teeth had at least 5 mm of attachment loss on the proximal surface tested. One proximal surface was scaled to remove all visible calculus using an ultrasonic scaler and the other proximal surface was root-planed with a Gracey curette. Specimens were cut from the scaled and root-planed proximal surfaces and divided into two groups: scaling group and root planing group. The Nd: YAG laser (power range 0-60 W, CW, 1064 nm) was used at a measured power output of 20 W. The irradiation time was 0.3, 0.5, 1, 2 or 3 s (3 mm beam diameter, distance from the tip to the specimen 5 cm), corresponding to an energy density of 84.93, 141.54, 283.09, 566.17 or 849.26 J/ cm
2, respectively. In both groups, the center of each specimen was used as the experimental area treated by laser irradiation and the peripheral area of the specimen served as a control. The specimens were then fixed and examined by SEM.
In the scaling group, the control area showed remaining calculus and cementum which had not been removed by the laser irradiation. The surface of the root-planed specimens was irregular, corresponding to the presence of a smear layer, and had an amorphous appearance. Root surfaces of the experimental area in the root planing group exhibited clear orifices of dentinal tubules and intertubular dentin without a smear layer.
The present results indicate that while Nd: YAG radiation is ineffective in removing residual calculus and cementum after scaling, it effectively removes the smear layer, uncovers dentinal tubules, and exposes collagen fibers on the root surface without widening the orifices of dentinal tubules after root planing.
View full abstract