Highly frequent comorbidity among personality disorders in DSM-IV has been regarded as a problem. This study quantitatively examined characteristics of overlap and specificity among borderline personality disorder(BPD), dependent personality disorder(DPD) and avoidant personality disorder(APD) tendencies; all of these include dependency as part of the diagnostic criteria. Japanese university students (
N=216) completed questionnaires with items about BPD, DPD and APD from the Japanese version of the SCID-II (Takahashi & Osone, 2002) and questions assessing ten personality styles (Nakazawa, 2004a). The results showed that these personality disorder tendencies overlapped in the following ways: higher self-inhibition, related to lacking confidence in their judgments and thoughts, and worrying about what other people think. Although specific BPD and DPD characteristics were found, no specific APD characteristics were identified in this study. The implications of these findings for underlying personality and latent factors of borderline, dependent and avoidant personality disorders are discussed.
View full abstract