In regular elementary school first-grade classes using group-teaching methods, some of the children do not learn to write hiragana syllables (a kind of Japanese writing system), even if they receive additional individual guidance. The purpose of the present study was to present the essential problems in teaching handwriting in a group setting and in individual guidance for children with writing difficulties. First-grade teachers were surveyed with a questionnaire that asked about the prevalence of handwriting difficulty in the students in their classes, the methods they used for group teaching and for individual guidance, problems in each of these teaching situations, and cues for improving teaching methods. The main results were as follows: (1) According to the teachers' reports, with group teaching, 7.1% of the children learned to write only incompletely, and 3.2% of the children did not show enough improvement even with individual guidance. (2) Tracing and copying were the main teaching methods; in group teaching, teachers paid attention to the sequence in which the strokes of the syllables were written. Individual guidance was generally undertaken within the group-teaching setting; the teaching methods were similar to those used in the group teaching. (3) In group teaching, matters to be investigated were the coping form with individual variations and the diagnostic method for each constituent-like writing sequence, the pencil grip, the form of the written syllable, and writing pressure. In individual guidance, a shortage of teaching time was a very serious problem, in addition to the problems pointed out in connection with group teaching. These results suggested that early improvement of teaching methods is necessary to deal with problems such as writing syllables with strokes in the wrong sequence, and other problems that arose because some children did not learn to write correctly with the current teaching methods. The teaching style for children with writing difficulties should be decided after careful consideration of the relationship between individual guidance and group teaching, because many teachers wished to give individual guidance in the group-teaching setting.
View full abstract