Bioethics
Online ISSN : 2189-695X
Print ISSN : 1343-4063
ISSN-L : 1343-4063
Different interpretations of 'withholding' and 'withdrawing' in life-sustaining treatments based on different conceptualizations of the human body or the relationship between the patient's intention and the condition
Koichiro KAWASHIMAMichiya ITO
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

2007 Volume 17 Issue 1 Pages 198-206

Details
Abstract
Interpretations of 'withholding' and 'withdrawing' in life-sustaining treatments becomes different depending on how we conceptualize the human body: whether we recognize it as an assembly of parts or as one holistic gestalt rather than a mere assembly of parts. Given that we focus on the relationship between the patient's intention and the condition he is in, if the patient accepts the condition, there can be withholding which means to follow the causal process; withdrawing is not intended in this case. If the patient does not accept his condition, there can be withholding and withdrawal used as a means to stop life-sustaining treatments. There is a clear difference in meaning between withholding conducted with the patient's acceptance of the condition and withholding as well as withdrawing conducted without the patient's acceptance of the condition.
Content from these authors
2007 Japan Association for Bioethics
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top