Kagaku tetsugaku
Online ISSN : 1883-6461
Print ISSN : 0289-3428
ISSN-L : 0289-3428
The Irreducibility of Linguistics to Biology
Limitations of Chomsky's Framework
Joseph Johnson
Author information
JOURNAL FREE ACCESS

2003 Volume 36 Issue 1 Pages 57-77

Details
Abstract
Chomsky claims that linguistics will become part of biology and that truths about language can be given in terms of facts about the brain. While allowing that psycholinguistic structures may be objects of science, I argue that any account of language must involve more than descriptions of the states of individuals. This implies that many linguistic truths cannot be reduced to neurobiological facts, or even captured on the psychological level within Chomsky's framework. Chomsky's rebuttals to arguments of this sort are examined, but found wanting. This leads to anomalous monism and doubts about whether propositionally construed entities will find analogues in brain science.
Content from these authors
© THE PHILOSOPHY OF SCIENCE SOCIETY,JAPAN
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top