The Proceedings of OPTIS
Online ISSN : 2424-3019
2022.14
Session ID : U00066
Conference information

Reconsideration of the Comparative Study between Extremal Optimization and Simulated Annealing
*Manabu HASEGAWA
Author information
CONFERENCE PROCEEDINGS RESTRICTED ACCESS

Details
Abstract

By regarding the solution updates in extremal optimization as a local search process, its intensification function is characterized by the downward interbasin dynamics observed in the cost landscape, and its functionality as well as the optimization performance is investigated for the solution of the traveling salesman problems. While the parameter dependence of these dynamics is similar to that observed previously for simulated annealing with constant temperature, the operating times needed to show their optimization ability differ significantly for the two methods. The comparative experiment is continued by considering the reciprocal relationship between smoothing the landscape and annealing the system. It is shown that, contrary to the original finding, thermal dynamics can be competitive with extremal dynamics in solution quality under the function-oriented operating condition.

Content from these authors
© 2022 The Japan Society of Mechanical Engineers
Previous article Next article
feedback
Top